Timothy O'Toole's Pub Chicago

"This Chicago sports bar has been around since 1992 in Streeterville, meaning the Bears fans have had only one Super Bowl appearance to celebrate since the bar’s been open. But fans can’t blame the Buffalo wings. These moist pieces of meat have a decent amount of red pepper spicy, aren’t too messy, and are well-balanced. While the Buffalo is the king, there are seven other sauces including sweet Thai chili and the Irish ghost (which is a Buffalo variant with ghost pepper powder)." - Ashok Selvam

"Since 1992, this lower-level Streeterville family-owned tavern has been a favorite for sports-viewing fans with some 48 beers on tap, award-winning wings, and hearty burgers." - Lisa Shames, Ashok Selvam

"A St. Patrick’s Day pop-up decorated with shamrocks and green lights, offering thematic food and celebratory cocktails." - Naomi Waxman

Casey wins the 4-pound Big Timmy Challenge: a 2-pound double cheeseburger with Monterey Jack, cheddar, Swiss and mozzarella cheeses, six slices of bacon, crispy onion straws, lettuce, tomato, pickles and red onion, along with a 2-pound side of Irish nachos (fries topped with melted cheddar, Swiss and Monterey Jack cheeses, crumbled bacon, and scallions.

"Drink specials win the day at subterranean sports bar Timothy O’Toole’s Pub. Beer options include $3 domestic drafts, $3.50 domestic bottles, and $4 select craft drafts such as Blue Moon and Lagunitas IPA. Customers can also pick up $5 mixed well drinks and $6 glasses of house wine. Happy hour is from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. on Monday through Friday." - Naomi Waxman