Stuffed Ice Cream

Ice cream shop · East Village

Stuffed Ice Cream

Ice cream shop · East Village

139 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003

Highlights

This narrow shop serves up delightful donut ice cream sandwiches, or "cruffs," alongside a parade of inventive flavors, perfect for a fun dessert outing.

139 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003 Get directions

stuffedicecreamnyc.com

@stuffedicecreamnyc

$ · Menu

@manvfood

LOST - "Giant Ice Cream Scoop Challenge", a 5 1/2 pound concoction featuring two flavors of ice cream - with each flavor using the equivalent of 11 normal scoops - stacked together (with crumbled Oreo cookies in the middle of them), shaped into a giant sphere, covered in fondant icing, sprinkled with Fruity Pebbles cereal, topped with a waffle cone (which is dipped in marshmallow fluff) and surrounded with decorative frosting; Casey, who chose "Cookie Monster" (Oreo, chocolate chip cookies, and brownie brittle) and Vietnamese coffee for his ice cream flavors.

Man Vs. Food - New York

View Postcard for Stuffed Ice Cream

Exploring Meerkats

Google

Fun & tasty ice cream flavors. Well worth the stop in for a scoop or a sandwich. The space is small, but there is seating in the rear. There is a freezer in the rear if you would like to grab some ice cream to go as well. There is usually at least one vegan option available.

Alan Varghese

Google

A great place to visit if you want a unique and Instagrammable dessert experience. Overall it was tasty but the ice cream could have been better. Staff is really friendly and they allow sampling. Prices are okay (Stuffed donut with 2 scoops is $9). Good selection of flavors (15+ with one vegan). A good one time experience. Would not recommend just getting the ice cream though because the ice cream was not something special and flavors didn't come as expected or that well.

Adrianne Cheung

Google

It actually had saved this ice cream shop for years, I finally paid a visit. I picked two flavors Ferrero rocher and my all time favorite ube pandan coconut in a waffle cone, they totally met my expectations.

Chris Smith

Google

The AC doesn’t really work too good which is a weird thing given it’s an ice cream place… the staff are friendly and prompt though so that helps. The donuts they use are stale and dry unfortunately, look good for pictures but would really help to have fresh or at least same day donuts. The ice cream barely helped the dryness of them. Cool novelty place but other than that wouldn’t care to go back unless they fix those things.

Isabelle Schilt

Google

I took my daughter for her birthday dessert after her party. The ice cream is good, but the place is underwhelming. They clearly have great marketing since the website and social pages make it look like a great experience with cute ice cream cone creations. There was only 1 staff member working and she wasn't overly helpful. They were also out of milk for milkshakes and do not have a public restroom.

sami shubert

Google

Stuffed is an excellent place to go!! Stuffed has fun flavors in a great location! When I was there I got the “Thai Kwon Dough” and I highly recommend it! I am not a coffee ice cream eater but I would definitely get it again. Even if you come to Stuffed hungry, you will leave.. well… STUFFED! I went with my family and they both got Cookie Monster with Cookie dough ice cream and they loved it! Awesome place!

Valentin Dorigny

Google

Best cookies monster ice cream ! Stuffed in a glazed donuts, it just can't get better. Had that over a festival during the summer and went back in their store to get some more. Price is good and pleasure it there. Hoping they'll open other location !

Shay

Google

I had a stuffed donut here today and loved it! They have a variety of ice cream flavours and the donut is so soft and tasty they compliment each other perfectly.

@manvfood

Man Vs. Food - New York

View Postcard for Stuffed Ice Cream

Exploring Meerkats

Google

Alan Varghese

Google

Adrianne Cheung

Google

Chris Smith

Google

Isabelle Schilt

Google

sami shubert

Google

Valentin Dorigny

Google

Shay

Google

I had a stuffed donut here today and loved it! They have a variety of ice cream flavours and the donut is so soft and tasty they compliment each other perfectly.