Petee's Pie Company

"This celebrated pie shop with locations at Delancey, Hell’s Kitchen, and Clinton Hill will offer a dozen of their best flavors for Thanksgiving, including apple, pumpkin, brown-butter honey pecan, and a distinctive black bottom almond chess, flavored with amaretto with a subtle chocolate ganache base well-balanced with the sweet chess filling. Staff favorite is the sweet potato pie, which distinguishes itself with a roasted, molasses-like flavor. Standard pies are $40. Six-inch varieties, available for six flavors, are $18 and available for pickup at all three locations. Petee’s extensive standard menu will also be available on very limited, space-permitting at their locations during the week of Thanksgiving." - Eater Staff, John Tsung

"Petra “Petee” Paradez’s pies don’t just taste amazing—they’re made with amazing ingredients, like seasonal local produce, organic flour, grass-fed butter, and natural fair-trade sweeteners. Those with dietary restrictions can also enjoy: their gluten-free and vegan options are just as delicious. Order a full pie for a special occasion, or stop by the Delancey Street storefront for a single slice—they’re open until 1am on weekends, making it the perfect pit stop on your way to the bars." - Passerbuys

"One peek into this rustic little bakery and you can tell that all the pies are made with love. We recently celebrated a team member's birthday with a magically delectable Salty Chocolate Chess cake. Be sure to ask about the gluten-free options available. We'd also suggest stepping in to try samples of all the pies they make as they offer the option to mix slices!" - Barrel

"Anyone who knows me knows that I am bonkers obsessed with Petee’s Pie Company, a sweet, sunny café in Manhattan that specializes in a different sort of New York slice: the fruit- and custard-filled varieties. I plan my whole life around these pies. When I was looking for a salon to frequent for my monthly haircut, I decided on a location that was a five-minute walk from Petee’s because I could get a slice of apple crumb or banana cream after my appointment. I take the J Train to the airport even though it’s not the most direct route because it picks me up close to Petee’s—and I can get my fill before I leave for Petee’s Pie–less destinations. In the fall, I bring pumpkin pie to Friendsgiving, and in the summer, key lime pie to the first picnic of the season. I’m the designated Pie Person within my circle of friends and I consider this the highest honor." - ByEsra Erol

"Petee's Pie Company, Little Italy Nolita by Barrel. One peek into this rustic little bakery and you can tell that all the pies are made with love. We recently celebrated a team member's birthday with a magically delectable Salty Chocolate Chess cake. Be sure to ask about the gluten-free options available. We'd also suggest stepping in to try samples of all the pies they make as they offer the option to mix slices!"