Petee's Pie Company

Pie shop · Lower East Side

13

@eater

"This celebrated pie shop with locations at Delancey, Hell’s Kitchen, and Clinton Hill will offer a dozen of their best flavors for Thanksgiving, including apple, pumpkin, brown-butter honey pecan, and a distinctive black bottom almond chess, flavored with amaretto with a subtle chocolate ganache base well-balanced with the sweet chess filling. Staff favorite is the sweet potato pie, which distinguishes itself with a roasted, molasses-like flavor. Standard pies are $40. Six-inch varieties, available for six flavors, are $18 and available for pickup at all three locations. Petee’s extensive standard menu will also be available on very limited, space-permitting at their locations during the week of Thanksgiving." - Eater Staff, John Tsung

Where to Get Thanksgiving Pies in NYC
Petee’s Pie Company

61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002 Get directions

peteespie.com
@peteespie

13 Postcards

See full details

More Places For You

Rampoldi New York

Restaurant · Upper West Side

Nestled near Lincoln Center, Rampoldi fuses Monegasque charm with a sleek ambiance, serving exquisite Italian-French dishes that impress every palate.

2 Postcards

Kaew Jao Jorm Thai williamsburg Brooklyn

Thai restaurant · Williamsburg

Kaew Jao Jorm is a hidden gem in East Williamsburg, serving up royal Thai dishes in a cozy, elegant setting that beautifully captures the essence of Thailand.

1 Postcard

Daily Provisions - Union Square

Restaurant · Gramercy

Nestled near Union Square, this cozy pastry haven by Danny Meyer dishes out fresh crullers, satisfying sandwiches, and a vibrant atmosphere that keeps locals coming back.

19 Postcards

Mel's

Pizza restaurant · Chelsea

This modern hotspot serves mouthwatering coal-fired pizzas and small plates alongside fab cocktails, all in a stylish, chill vibe.

15 Postcards

JG Melon

Bar & grill · Upper East Side

Step into this cash-only gem, where a chill vibe and classic décor meet a bustling crowd, serving up solid bar burgers and top-notch chili.

44 Postcards

Thelewala

Indian restaurant · Greenwich Village

This tiny late-night gem on MacDougal serves up bold Kolkata-style kathi rolls and flavorful chaats, perfect for a snack after a night out.

12 Postcards

Pan Pan

Bakery · Greenpoint

Pan Pan Vino Vino in Greenpoint serves up artisan pastries by day and transforms into a cozy wine bar at night, offering a laid-back vibe and inventive small plates.

6 Postcards

PIXIE SCOUT

Caterer · Crown Heights

Pixie Scout is your go-to culinary team crafting fresh, local delicacies that elevate any event, making every meal a memorable experience.

1 Postcard

Carnegie Hall

Concert hall · Midtown West

Carnegie Hall is an iconic music venue renowned for its stunning architecture, rich history, and world-class acoustics that make every performance unforgettable.

4 Postcards

Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels

Bagel shop · South Slope

At Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels in Park Slope, dive into a bagel haven featuring chewy classics and inventive sandwiches, perfect for any time of day.

11 Postcards