Nick & Toni's

"An Italian-inspired restaurant in a Tuscan-inspired farmhouse setting, prioritizing local freshness with its daily whole fish and market catch." - Adam H. Callaghan

"A local staple since 1988, this Tuscan restaurant is always full of friends and families enjoying wood-fired pizzas and dishes like the catch of the day dressed in olive tapenade. Come for wine and a farm-to-table menu seamlessly merging local produce with pastas like housemade ricotta cavatelli. Reservations are easy to make for groups of up to 10, and groups of 11-20 can book a $125 per person prix-fixe on the covered back patio. There’s no kids’ menu, and strollers and pets aren’t allowed, so expect a more rule-following crowd that’s still eager to get after some rosé and spaghetti." - melissa kravitz hoeffner, team infatuation

"Alec Baldwin, Gwyneth Paltrow, Jerry Seinfeld, Steven Spielberg, and Robert De Niro are some of the entertainment-world names who can be seen at Nick & Toni’s restaurant in East Hampton or at one of the movie premieres that take place in the East Hampton and Southampton theaters." - Jay McInerney

"A local staple since 1988, this Tuscan restaurant is always full of friends and families enjoying wood-fired pizzas and dishes like the catch of the day dressed in olive tapenade. Come for wine and a farm-to-table menu seamlessly merging local produce with pastas like housemade ricotta cavatelli. Reservations are easy to make for groups of up to 10, and groups of 11-20 can book a $125 per person prix-fixe on the covered back patio. There’s no kids’ menu, and strollers and pets aren’t allowed, so expect a more rule-following crowd that’s still eager to get after some rosé and spaghetti." - Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner

"A visit to celebrity-favorite Nick and Toni’s may not be the same without sightings of regulars like Paul McCartney, Alec Baldwin, and Martha Stewart, but the takeout menu still features some top-notch Italian fare. The beef and pork meatball pomodoro with polenta, reginetti pasta with lamb ragu and ricotta, and sea scallops with roasted carrots are all on deck, as are pizza kits, and meals prepped for two." - Beth Landman