Nagle’s Bagels

Bagels at this place are always fresh, large, and satisfying. I usually get two meals out of one because I can't finish it all at once. The atmosphere is chill, with cool music playing and a welcoming vibe.

Great spot. A nice variety of bagel sandwiches that are all very delicious! Loved the Blue Velvet and then went back the next day for the Veggie Sandwich.

The service is as phenomenal as the bagels!! Adorable little bagel place. One of the best Egg Everything bagels I’ve ever had. The atmosphere is lovely and made for a great morning. We had the Veggie Nagle and the special.

I work at Akwaaba, a black owned bed and breakfast in bed stuy. In summer of 2023 one of my guests who got married at Akwaaba ordered from your location as lunch for their bridal party. They were kind enough to say that I should look at the menu and they would order me something too. I ordered the blue velvet, and it was absolutely amazing! Often I would think about the bagel, but couldn’t remember the name of the place they ordered from, nor could I remember the name of the sandwich! I would get so frustrated when I would get the craving for it….Today February 3rd, 2025 I decided to do some research looking for bagel spots near me and I found you guys!!! And you did not disappoint!!! Thank you for the creativity!! I am a true foodie and that blue velvet sandwich makes me happy lol 🤣 it’s so fresh, sweet and savory!! It’s my favorite combination!! Will definitely be ordering from you guys for a future event I have!!! 🙌🏾🙏🏾✨❤️🥰 MY NEW FAVORITE SPOT!!!

This is a cozy spot with some great food and really friendly staff. If it's looking pretty full, don't let the wait time scare you off! We got there at a really busy time ~10:30 am on a holiday so the place was pretty full. Lots of folks standing inside and outside. We were able to order quickly and the people at the register were calling names both inside and outside to make sure everyone was able to get their order. It was a really nice day so we didn't mind waiting a bit outside, but someone who I assume was the manager came out to set up some chairs and a table for us while we waited. When our order was ready, the staff brought it out with a smile - excellent customer service!

service is a little slow but the quality of the product and service is why, it’s a bustling and quaint location amongst a bunch of cool little shoppes and the selection/ prices are all great. the bagels are super soft and not too chewy, tuna salad was well seasoned and overall loved this place. they also gave my friend a free gift just cause they inquired if certain things were for sale- love this place!!!

We went recently on a weekend morning and it was packed, everyone was waiting for their orders outside. Eventually one of the staff brought us a table to sit outdoors! Really friendly and considerate. Plus, the bagel was delicious, the perfect chew and full of fresh ingredients.

I ordered the New Yorker Sandwich and an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Both tasted like something I could make at home and not something I paid $20 for. My bagel was barely toasted and the scallion cream cheese didn’t have much of a taste. My eggs were really brown and there was very little egg, bacon, and cheese on the sandwich.everything was mediocre at best for the price. Also, the bathroom is basically in the kitchen and the door is open half the time - doesn’t feel very sanitary. I read lots of reviews on the coffee & it’s good, but this tastes exactly like my bodega coffee that I spend $1.50 on (not the $3 I spent at this place). On top of this, they took about 30 minutes to fulfill my order. There were so many people waiting on their orders inside and outside. Only redeeming them quality was the hard working & kind employees