This laid-back deli serves up mouthwatering Reubens and deep-dish pies, all while boasting friendly service and a menu packed with fresh ingredients.
"This is one of those places that I would have never tried, or probably even noticed, unless a friend had not recommended it to me. There are only a handful of spots in the city that are worth getting deep dish pizza at and this is one of them. Really great sauce and the dough isn’t obnoxiously thick. Also, Li’l Guys, which shares the space, features a Reuben sandwich that has bread made to order, pretty fantastic." - Lee Zelenak
"My Pie & Li'l Guys, Bucktown. This is one of those places that I would have never tried, or probably even noticed, unless a friend had not recommended it to me. There are only a handful of spots in the city that are worth getting deep dish pizza at and this is one of them. Really great sauce and the dough isn’t obnoxiously thick. Also, Li’l Guys, which shares the space, features a Reuben sandwich that has bread made to order, pretty fantastic."
Lisa Khabeer
Lucy Burg
Jack Erffmeyer
Andrew Thorrens
Diane Soulliere
Madison Friduss
Emily Warpinski
Corinne Kopsky
Elisabeth C.
Aesha E.
Claudia R.
Melanie V.
Ashley S.
Akshay S.
Alexander M.
Jacob J.
Mark J.
Igor C.
Doreen H.
Jeff P.
Sarah R.
Ivanka B.
Alex C.
Kathleen R.
Stephen M.
Kevin A.
Sharlene K.
Dane K.
Keith D.
Danny W.
Hugh B.
Brian S.
Leang E.
Sarah V.
Brent W.
Timothy M.
J l.
Robyn M.
Josh W.
Caroline C.
Kelly R.
Amanda P.
Lory M.
Maggie E.
Stephanie S.
Robert S.
leyla a.
Mickey M.
Allison V.
Keith A.
Joseph T.
Raquel D.
Lauren S.
Ron R.
Katie K.
J. M.
David A.