Jonny's Pizza

One of the thinnest and crunchiest pizza slices I've had! There weren't that many options on the menu (just 4 with 2 add-on's) but they hit the spot in pizza craving. The vodka sauce with pepperoni flavoring was perfect, and the hot honey was a good addition to the pepperoni. The staff was friendly and patient with my requests. There's not that much standing room inside but it's fine if you're on the go or a pizza crawl ;)

The LES side has been lacking an elite slice of Pizza since Scarr's moved locations in June 2023. It went from a great slice to a good slice, and good truly is the enemy of great. Over the past month, I've heard a lot of rumblings surrounding Jonny's as a potential elite slice. My Big bro and I walked in on Halloween Weekend, the only ones not in a costume. It was PACKED in here. We waited in a short line that moved pretty quick, as the employees here were going HAM cranking out pie after pie. They keep it simple with only 4 options for slices: Cheese, Pepperoni, Vodka, and Vodka Pep. I asked homie at the register what the move was, and he said without hesitation: "Vodka Pep." I like that confidence. I got a vodka pep and a cheese slice, because you can always tell how good a place will be based on their cheese slice. Big bro and I both grabbed a Mexican coke and waited for our pizza. All the girls in here were breaking their necks checking out my big bro. I get it though he is really handsome... After about 7 minutes, we got our slices. This is an ELITE slice of pizza. Quintessential NY style, great hold on the undercarriage, and a crunch on every bite. Artistry. The vodka slice was the perfect vodka sauce to pep ratio, as some vodka slices put WAY too much vodka sauce. This was my favorite vodka slice I've had in the city. I'd put Jonny's right up there with L'Industrie and Cello's for my favorite slices in nyc. It's a HUGE pick up for the LES. Oddly reminiscent of when the Lakers traded for Pau Gasol back in February 2008… IG @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews

We stopped in for a couple of slices and they really hit the spot! The pizza is nice and crispy on the bottom and we loved the vodka sauce flavor topped with hot honey!

Amazing pizza, excellent ambiance, good music, the vodka slice goes fire. I adore the staff here. Josh was so friendly and helpful. Ivon was so sweet and help me decide between all the slices. The service was so fast even though there was a line down the block. I ended up trying all flavors. but again the vodka is my favorite. Not only will I be back, but I'll be bringing my friends and my family here. Best slice in the LES!!!

pizza quality in NYC has always been pretty good, but the last decade...overall quality is up and there's really no need to settle for average pizza especially in the Lower Side. Jonny's Pizza is a corner spot on Orchard Street. it is a nice uncluttered spot with a few tall standing tables to eat at as well as one bench if you want to sit. it very much is a place to grab a slice or two or a pie and keep it moving. the staff is friendly and very responsive when you enter or if you have questions. the menu is pretty small there's a few different slice types: a plain cheese slice, pepperoni slice, vodka slice, or pepperoni vodka slice.. each slice (or pie) is finished with fresh basil leaves and grated cheese (parmesan, i think) out of the oven. for an additional charge, you can add hot honey or a dollop of burrata cheese. what I got: 1) cheese slice; the aroma from the pizza and basil is so good. a crispy thin slice of pizza with some give (not crackery, but firm with no crust flop). the crust is kinda airy with even air bubbles throughout for that light feel with a nice amount of chew in the crust. the sauce is a layer of tomatoes that has flavor but doesn't weigh down the slice and has more of a sweet note than a garlicky one. the mozzarella is a thin layer of stretchy rich cheesiness atop the slice. good stuff 2) the real winner is the pepperoni vodka slice with hot honey drizzled all over. this slice has a variety of flavors mixed into one: the mild heat sweetness of the hot honey (not too spicy at all), the savoriness of the crispy pepperoni, and the richness tomato creaminess of the vodka sauce + mozzarella atop the a thin crust slice. if you like pizza and want something that is all things pizza + something extra; this slice is for you. all in all a tasty slice. Always wash down quality pizza with a bubbly beverage like a Mexican Coke which is what I got. Jonny’s Pizza has a variety of soft beverages. Jonny's ran out of burrata, the night i was there, but it was fairly late. and i probably would have stuck with my buratta-less order regardless bc it was very good and satisfying. nice addition to the LES and definitely someplace for quick bite, late night slice, or a pie to scarf down while watching a game with the amigos.

As you can see I didn’t even wait to take a picture that’s how amazing it is. I had the pepperoni vodka sauce and it was once again amazing the sauce is so rich and tasty and the additional shredded cheese is a great touch. Definitely recommend the Sicily blood orange soda great Bev.

I didn’t know I needed vodka sauce on pizza but it tastes great. Crispy New York slices with a good amount of crunch and not too much grease. Cool for a night out near great nightlife options.

incredible sauce on every slice, and the bit of basil on each is an nice touch. perfect crisp, not floppy, and not too cheesy. this is gonna become one of NYC’s best slices soon. + there’s space inside and good service?book it.

One of the thinnest and crunchiest pizza slices I've had! There weren't that many options on the menu (just 4 with 2 add-on's) but they hit the spot in pizza craving. The vodka sauce with pepperoni flavoring was perfect, and the hot honey was a good addition to the pepperoni. The staff was friendly and patient with my requests. There's not that much standing room inside but it's fine if you're on the go or a pizza crawl ;)

The LES side has been lacking an elite slice of Pizza since Scarr's moved locations in June 2023. It went from a great slice to a good slice, and good truly is the enemy of great. Over the past month, I've heard a lot of rumblings surrounding Jonny's as a potential elite slice. My Big bro and I walked in on Halloween Weekend, the only ones not in a costume. It was PACKED in here. We waited in a short line that moved pretty quick, as the employees here were going HAM cranking out pie after pie. They keep it simple with only 4 options for slices: Cheese, Pepperoni, Vodka, and Vodka Pep. I asked homie at the register what the move was, and he said without hesitation: "Vodka Pep." I like that confidence. I got a vodka pep and a cheese slice, because you can always tell how good a place will be based on their cheese slice. Big bro and I both grabbed a Mexican coke and waited for our pizza. All the girls in here were breaking their necks checking out my big bro. I get it though he is really handsome... After about 7 minutes, we got our slices. This is an ELITE slice of pizza. Quintessential NY style, great hold on the undercarriage, and a crunch on every bite. Artistry. The vodka slice was the perfect vodka sauce to pep ratio, as some vodka slices put WAY too much vodka sauce. This was my favorite vodka slice I've had in the city. I'd put Jonny's right up there with L'Industrie and Cello's for my favorite slices in nyc. It's a HUGE pick up for the LES. Oddly reminiscent of when the Lakers traded for Pau Gasol back in February 2008… IG @jnov_ Tiktok @jnov_reviews

We stopped in for a couple of slices and they really hit the spot! The pizza is nice and crispy on the bottom and we loved the vodka sauce flavor topped with hot honey!

Amazing pizza, excellent ambiance, good music, the vodka slice goes fire. I adore the staff here. Josh was so friendly and helpful. Ivon was so sweet and help me decide between all the slices. The service was so fast even though there was a line down the block. I ended up trying all flavors. but again the vodka is my favorite. Not only will I be back, but I'll be bringing my friends and my family here. Best slice in the LES!!!

pizza quality in NYC has always been pretty good, but the last decade...overall quality is up and there's really no need to settle for average pizza especially in the Lower Side. Jonny's Pizza is a corner spot on Orchard Street. it is a nice uncluttered spot with a few tall standing tables to eat at as well as one bench if you want to sit. it very much is a place to grab a slice or two or a pie and keep it moving. the staff is friendly and very responsive when you enter or if you have questions. the menu is pretty small there's a few different slice types: a plain cheese slice, pepperoni slice, vodka slice, or pepperoni vodka slice.. each slice (or pie) is finished with fresh basil leaves and grated cheese (parmesan, i think) out of the oven. for an additional charge, you can add hot honey or a dollop of burrata cheese. what I got: 1) cheese slice; the aroma from the pizza and basil is so good. a crispy thin slice of pizza with some give (not crackery, but firm with no crust flop). the crust is kinda airy with even air bubbles throughout for that light feel with a nice amount of chew in the crust. the sauce is a layer of tomatoes that has flavor but doesn't weigh down the slice and has more of a sweet note than a garlicky one. the mozzarella is a thin layer of stretchy rich cheesiness atop the slice. good stuff 2) the real winner is the pepperoni vodka slice with hot honey drizzled all over. this slice has a variety of flavors mixed into one: the mild heat sweetness of the hot honey (not too spicy at all), the savoriness of the crispy pepperoni, and the richness tomato creaminess of the vodka sauce + mozzarella atop the a thin crust slice. if you like pizza and want something that is all things pizza + something extra; this slice is for you. all in all a tasty slice. Always wash down quality pizza with a bubbly beverage like a Mexican Coke which is what I got. Jonny’s Pizza has a variety of soft beverages. Jonny's ran out of burrata, the night i was there, but it was fairly late. and i probably would have stuck with my buratta-less order regardless bc it was very good and satisfying. nice addition to the LES and definitely someplace for quick bite, late night slice, or a pie to scarf down while watching a game with the amigos.

As you can see I didn’t even wait to take a picture that’s how amazing it is. I had the pepperoni vodka sauce and it was once again amazing the sauce is so rich and tasty and the additional shredded cheese is a great touch. Definitely recommend the Sicily blood orange soda great Bev.

I didn’t know I needed vodka sauce on pizza but it tastes great. Crispy New York slices with a good amount of crunch and not too much grease. Cool for a night out near great nightlife options.

incredible sauce on every slice, and the bit of basil on each is an nice touch. perfect crisp, not floppy, and not too cheesy. this is gonna become one of NYC’s best slices soon. + there’s space inside and good service?book it.

Best slice of pizza I've had in a long time!! I came to try the vodka pizza - the sauce was to die for and the dough was the perfect mix of crispy and doughy. I was craving coming back as soon as I left that I came back the next day with friends and got to try more of the menu. You 1000% need to get the vodka or pepperoni vodka slice and I recommend getting the burrata and hot honey add ons. You honestly should just try it all bc the garlic knots were incredible and they came with a side of the vodka sauce plus this Italian orange soda was so refreshing! Can't wait to go back!!

I never leave reviews but after trying Jonny's pizza, I truly felt the need to. Legitimately the best vodka slice I've ever had - especially with the hot honey add-on. This is the type of slice you go out of your way to get. I can't wait to go back again. You can tell that Jonny really took his time to create the perfect NY slice of pizza. He's down to earth and cares about his craft. Excited to have found this hidden gem early before it starts having lines out the door. High quality, delicious late-night pizza served by a genuine, dedicated guy. 100/10 - this is top-tier pizza that actually stands out in a city filled with a million different slice shops. can't wait to see it inevitably blow up soon.

the pizza is amazing, delicious, crispy and the owner is hot. doesn't get much better!

Thin crust, tasty vodka sauce, fresh basil, what more can you ask for? They have a small menu but they get every aspect right.

Super solid pizza spot for a late night slice! We came here and got two cheese slices each, one with the burrata. The slices were delicious, not too thick with great tomato sauce, and very good flavor. The burrata was also great though I'd recommend getting a slide without it. The spot was big enough to get to have a standing table when eating which was good. Service was also super quick! Will be back if I'm in the area!

Stopped by on a Thursday around 6:30 and it was slammed! My boyfriend and I both got a slice of vodka and a slice of cheese. Both were solid NY slices! I personally loved the vodka slice! Very quick and easy operation. We may have waited 5 minutes. The only qualm was that it was packed and not where to stand or eat. If they had a standing table or two outside, it would be perfect! Absolutely worth it, and will 100% be back!

Another pizza place in Manhattan? Yes. This one is really good. This one is on a sun drenched corner on Orchard Street. We were there shortly after they opened at noon. Nice young fellas serving the slices. Jonny is a lot younger than you would think. A Lakers fan from Los Angeles. You would not know it from the early Beatles and Stones playing over the loudspeakers. The thin crust pizza is really great. This place will give Scarr's down the street some serious competition. Really great pizza. Nice tunes, too.

I was excited to try this place out due to the reviews but I was a bit disappointed. They ran out of burrata and pepperoni. I got a vodka and a regular slice. I was happy with the basil on it but I would have liked more. The sauce for regular is just okay. The crusts are too well done and crispy for me. The vodka sauce is better but I don't know if id go again.

Amazing pizza, giving lindustrie a run for its money! Thin crispy New York slices with tons of flavor. Vodka was my favorite, but you can't go wrong with any. Standing space only and no seating, but each slice is finished with fresh parm and basil to order. Delicious and will be back!!

Incredible pizza. Truly very up there for us on the ranks for best pizza in NYC. Tried the vodka slice with burrata and classic cheese slice. They nailed the consistency we all love which is thin crispy but not too thin. It was packed with flavor and what really elevated it was the fresh grated Parmesan cheese and mint leaves (also have an option to add hot honey). Needless to say we will be back soon. Also honorable mention to the Sicilian drink - a must get

This pizza honestly blew my mind. I've waited in line for popular pizza joints and this pizza was equally if not better. If you're looking for not too oily pizza that is savory, thin, crispy, and delicious, this is your place! The vodka pep was unique and hit all the spots! Vodka is great too! I got a plain cheese with burrata on it- it was divine! The team there was also friendly, place was clean and ambiance was modern. Taste: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Ambiance: 5/5

Not a sit down place but it is worth a visit and I will be coming back again. The moment you come in, you can tell you are in for a fresh slice. In the display counter you see fresh basil and blocks of Parmigian cheese which they scrape onto your slice. The choices are limited to cheese and vodka slices and the toppings are burrata, hot honey and pepperoni. Due to the focused menu, they do everything well. I had the cheese slice with hot honey and burrata and the other a vodka with pepperoni. Both were topped with fresh Parmigian and basil. The crust on both were thin, crisp and crunchy. The tomato sauce on the plain was very good. The star of the show was the vodka slices, so rich and tasty. These must have been the best vodka slices I have had. I tried them elsewhere but did not like them. My only suggestion is I do wish they would have 2 small sit down tables here. The cashier was nice and friendly and gave us recommendations. I normally do not like orange soda due to the artificial taste and color. But here their Italian blood orange soda from Italy with actual blood orange juice paired well with our slices.

Vodka: 4.5/5, Pepperoni: 3/5 We arrived at Jonny's Pizza for the Yelp Event and got the Pepperoni slice and the Vodka Pepperoni slice. The pizza was thin, crisp, and perfectly cooked at the bottom. But having preferred more saucy pizzas, I would say I liked the Vodka much more than the Pepperoni. The Vodka sauce was not overly sweet, and it definitely hit the spot! The Pepperoni felt a bit dry and lacking in sauce. The basil and cheese felt fresh though, and service was quick. It is worth to note that there is no seating area inside or outside the establishment. There was only a standing area with some high tops which was busy and a bit chaotic at times, as the store began to fill up. Highly recommend the Vodka, but I would skip the Pepperoni.

Yummy pizza w super nice staff! Came here for lunch on Saturday and it was great :) I got two slices and they were bigger than most slices in other places, so I was quite full! I got two vodka pepperoni w hot honey and it was delicious. The hot honey was a great addition! The normal cheese pizza w burrata was also recommended! Overall, great place for a quick bite!

Small pizza shop in East Village that serves a great NYC slice. Thin crust, little greasy, and perfect amount of crunch. Highly recommend if you're in the area and want to get a slice. Highly recommend the Vodka slice, I think it's better than the cheese.

Super fresh ingredients! The hours of business will have you coming here after a good night out! The pizza isnt greasy and was very light yet I was still nice and filled. We got the Hot honey vodka, vodka pepperoni and cheese with buratta with vodka. Loved that they put fresh basil on top! Its exactly what youre looking for in a NY slice. Very delicious and clean! Will absolutely come here again!

Really really good pizza in LES!! I'm so glad I was introduced to the pizza here because it now rates as one of my favs in the area! The space is what you would expect from a walk in slice shop, there's a bench and standing room. They add parm to each slice so there's no parm in the shakers but it's not needed! The slices are good on their own. Staff is also nice. I started with the cheese slice but elevated it with the burrata cheese add on, and it's only $1.50 extra which is a craaaazy deal!! Def add the cheese! It's so good! They top each scoop of burrata with olive oil and salt and omg it was so tasty. I also really like they add basil to each slice which also adds good flavor to the slice. I also tried the pepperoni and added burrata and hot honey. It was good and again the burrata def elevated the slice. Another thing I loved is that the slices are crispy and don't flop. The crust is also really good and flavorful on its own. It's both chewy and crispy. Def a good slice!

We went for a couple slices and a drink and were happy with everything at Jonny's. Slices were solid, sauce was flavorful (a bit on the sweeter side which I don't mind), crust was excellent, and toppings choices were awesome. Service was friendly and the space has a solid amount of space for a slice shop

Great customer service, very cheerful cashier. The slices are solid, the burrata made them extra special. Vodka sauce is slightly spicy, wasn't expecting that, but it's good.

Quite honestly, this was maybe the best slice I've had in a bit. True ny slice energy with the perfect crispness, being able to be folded in half AND keep its shape takes perfection in pizza craftsmanship. We tried every single slice and none disappointed. The vodka pepperoni was my personal favorite esp with the hot honey on top!! Will come back for a slice~ the service was amazing as well! She was so kind and explained with excitement !!! The space is cute too, a lil bench in the center of the store was kinda cute haha

I took the train from Harlem to check out this spot, and it was worth the trip! I apologize for no pictures as I was on the move. The two slices I had were delicious! I had a cheese and the house pepperoni a la vodka, both with sprinkle cheese. The service was prompt and friendly, and the corner shop had two open-air sides with lots of tables for counter eating and a few tables. I'll def be back!

Great pizza. Highly recommending coming in a giving the pizza a try. On weekday early hours the place isn't too busy so you can get your order quite fast. Ambience is like any other pizza place without really any seats so mostly just standing around and eating. It is near a place with a lot of night life so if craving some late night food, a good place to grab a quick bite.

I really liked how their cheese pizza had basil and herbs on it. It was only $3.25. It was one of the best pizzas I have ever had in New York and it wasn't only because I had drunk cravings. The dough was at the perfect crisp, the sauce and cheese ratio were perfect, and the value was incredible. The line at 3am was about a 10 minute wait, and just like it says in other reviews, this spot is going to get so popular so get Jonny's Pizza before it really blows up!

Thin crispy crust that can hold up to the sauce, cheese, and toppings. Loved the fresh basil and the vodka sauce. The edges are light and airy as well!

Jonny was there himself to help out his servers and he was so nice! Ambiance was modern and clean, and there's a bench in the middle of the store to sit on but otherwise it's mostly a standing room / takeout spot. Pizza was really good - highly recommend the vodka pepperoni, the slices were thin and I loved the fresh basil on top.

Amazing new slice spot at the great corner where the first Zazzy's Pizza was. Owned by a former employee of 7th Street Burger, the menu is very similar in how simple it is: the whole thing currently is just 4 types of slices, plus Mexican Coke and Water. Get a classic Cheese, plus a Pepperoni or Vodka, or a Pepperoni AND Vodka together. The Vodka-Roni is amazing, and makes it immediately apparent that Jonny received some tips and help along the way from the late, great Andrew Bellucci. In fact the slices here are quite similar to the great pizza from Andrew Bellucci's Pizzeria. As long as he can maintain this consistency here as he extends his hours to the daytime eventually, he will have a contender for one of the top slices in the city.

Go ahead and try and find a better looking slice. You won't find it. New #1 in the city. Perfect flop Perfect crisp Fresh as it gets Great story Go here. You won't regret it.

Wow this pizza spot blew my mind away. I was looking for pizza and happened to walk past this one. I expected it to be any other NY pizza spot but it was SO MUCH BETTER. Definitely a lot of drunk people at 3am but the line moved pretty quickly. They have a tight selection--cheese, pepperoni, vodka and vodka pep. I got a cheese slice and I was so pleasantly surprised they added fresh basil. SUCH a nice touch and really elevates the slice. The cheese was $3.25 which is very well priced for the quality in my opinion. I would come back regularly just to get pizza from here I think it's my new favorite pizza slice spot!!!

This was one of the best pizza slices I've had in a while! The thin crust was crispy but not so hard it cuts you just to bite the crust. I got the cheese with burrata add on and the vodka and they were both so good. The slices weren't overly oily and I really liked how they added basil leaves on top to add to the flavor. $3.95 for a basic cheese slice is also such a hard find these days!

In the land of mediocre pizza that is NYC in 2024, this stands out. I love that they grate cheese and put basil leaves on it for you. $4.50 fer a slice a pep, you get a lot less other places in NYC these days.

I'm a very critical pizza snob - this is must-try NYC pizza, esp if you're in LES. Highly recommend vodka sauce + pepperoni, definitely add hot honey and burrata. My vegetarian friend loved the vodka slice

Ordered a whole vodka pepperoni and ran it home. (5 mins) SO GOOD. Crust has a great chew and depth of flavor. Vodka sauce phenomenal. Fresh basil and shaved parm nice touch. 10/10 and I am VERY picky about my pizza. Jonny's is the LES's answer to L'Industrie and Mamas Too.

Pizza was very good. Bendable and tasty! I wish I would have gotten more during my stay in NY.

On of my favorite slices in the city! The parm they grate on top made it stand out. Small menu, but I loved the vodka slice.

Delicious thin crust pizza with crispy undercarriage. I had their vodka and cheese slices and they were both really good. Dough had great flavor (I usually don't love the crust but this one was amazing), just the right amount of cheese so the pizza didn't get floppy, and sauce had rich flavor as well. These slices were better than both Mama Too and L'Industrie. Great service as well, the employees were very friendly and nice. It's also a fun place to stay and eat inside with a really lively atmosphere, also very close to a lot of fun bars.

Awesome vodka slice with pepperoni. They shave cheese on top of the pizza as well. Make sure to add hot honey to the pizza too

Amazing slice. Best vodka slice in the city. Portnoy 9.8. Don't forget about us day ones once you blow up