Jason T.
Yelp
First off, we went here solely because of Chris Barton from Anew Table. We loved his restaurant, and was always blown away by the set menu's. Anew was 11/10 stars.
The good stuff; great decor, perfect level of attentiveness and personality from the staff.
The bad stuff; We did the 'tasting' menu ($100 a person, two person table). I did not ever really read much into the menu, as I was excited to get the Anew experience again. Sourdough bread, and salted butter as a complimentary appy. I can save you a longer read, by telling you this was the best part.
Next came a single cracker, with some beef tartar. I am unsure about the presentation expectation, but the cracker had been slid around the plate, so what appeared to be a trail of yellowish oil was not necessarily enticing. The cracker bite was bland, no seasoning. Cold dish.
Second was a strip of shredded crab, on a leek, some more oil, and some greens. The odor was not a pleasant odor, and again the flavour was bland. Two bites. Cold dish.
Third was a beet salad. Calling it salad is a stretch. Some diced beets, on pickled cabbage, and sprinkled with bee pollen. Flat out not good. Bee pollen is basically tiny hard bits of yellowish chalk. About ten fork fulls, so decent sized dish, but not edible, we tried. Cold dish.
Fourth was sablefish on pork belly, with a leek, and some creamed celerac. The pervasive theme was no seasoning. Two bites of each bit. Warm dish, except for the leek.
Fifth was steak of some sort, but sadly only three'ish bites, not tender, pretty tough chew. There was a small single bite tart, with some dry protein, and no seasoning again, no moisture left in it at all. Warm dish.
There was a dish of apple butter, cheese, and some crackers sent out, as we didn't finish the beets. Very thoughtful of the kitchen / server, and again they did an excellent job.
Final was the desert. I believe it was a pavlova, with a berry sauce, and lemon curd on the top. There was lemon rind on top, that was imbedded in the sauce, and the palatability of sisal rope. Perhaps it was supposed to be candied, maybe I was supposed to remove and not eat it. The pavlova was done well, but the berry sauce has zero sweetness, only tart, and the lemon curd was all tart, and a tiny bit sweet. This was a mouth inverting bitter / tart ride. Not good.
With four drinks (two glasses wine, two tap beer), and tip, this was a $330 dinner. I paid less at Anew, and would have paid this amount to have that prior experience. This was top five worst meals I have ever experienced. Every dish was tiny, not seasoned, not visually pleasing (white flavourless celerac cream on white plate....), largely not warm, flat out not good.
I don't know what happened, but Dean House is not Anew table. Now I know, and it's sad that it isn't. Maybe the super expensive real estate has cut into the ability to present cohesive, engaging, delicious pre-set menu's? Maybe, having management / investors / association with another restaurant has hamstrung Chris Barton? Maybe just having to offer a full optional menu, and trying to offer a pre-set experience, can't live in the same space?
As we sat through this, we didn't see anyone else do the tasting menu. I feel we chose wrong. The other patron's selections all looked great, and filled their plates. We won't go back. But, I will go to the next venue Chris Barton finds himself at (and at the helm again), as I have hope of experiencing what was, once again!