Lena Mazur
Google
For my birthday, we decided to try Osteria Stella and since we didn't have a reservation our only option was the reduced menu at Brother Wolf.
Let me start off by saying I love their cocktails, especially during the Peppermint Trail, but was not impressed at all with the food.
The plan was to have our meal in true Italian family style. Bought 3 apps and figured these would be sufficient. The meatballs, fried artichokes, bruschetta. Meatballs were tiny and a bit dense. Fried artichokes were mostly tiny little pieces, it felt like we ended up with mostly scraps from other orders, only a few good size pieces. And they were very heavy on the lemon flavor. The bruschetta was approximately 2 bites and done. They did give a little more topping than bread which was nice, except we had nothing to eat it with, just a waste. When these tiny apps did not fill us we ordered our dishes. My son got the linguini with clams. It was one small scoop of pasta and 3, maybe 4 tiny baby clams. My husband ordered the Cacio E Pepe, which was almost raw pasta. Truly, we make el dente all the time and this was also uncooked boxed pasta. The sauce itself was so conjealed that he would stick his fork to the top of the pasta and held it over his dish. It took almost a whole minute for the noodle to start pulling away. I ordered the gnnochi, they were not heavenly little pillows as they should be and just smothered in pesto as if to hide their imperfections.
Do recommend swining in for a great cocktail, but caution against ordering the food. It's way overpriced for the quantity and quality.