The top Italian Restaurants in New York City [2023]
Piccola Cucina Estiatorio
Italian restaurant · SoHo
Piccola Cucina Estiatorio is a must-visit in the bustling SoHo neighbourhood of New York City. You won't find anyone better than them when it comes to Italian food. The restaurant has an atmosphere that will make you feel as if you stepped into an Italian fanily kitchen, and the servers are incredibly helpful and attentive. The house special, the Tagliatelle Verdi con Ragu topped with black truffle, must not be missed and offers oodles of flavor. Other popular dishes include their lasagna and arancine, both of which are succulent and so authentic that they could have been made in Bologna. Piccola Cucina Estiatorio is the number one Italian restaurant you can find in New York City, and we highly recommend it for a taste of Italy. Make sure to book ahead for the evening in order to ensure a spot, or drop in for lunch for their fabulous
San Carlo Osteria Piemonte
Italian restaurant · SoHo
San Carlo Osteria Piemonte boasts an atmosphere like no other. With its subtle but elegant decor, accented with touches of Italy, customers will feel like visitors in a corner of the Mediterranean. And the food does not disappoint. An offering of authentic Italian dishes, ranging from succulent meats to expertly roasted vegetables, each carefully crafted dish shows that San Carlo takes its craft seriously. For a truly memorable experience, opt for the Pulpo, a tender octopus dish cooked in white wine and lemon juice. Served with potato puree, the Pulpo is bursting with flavour and the perfect accompaniment for a glass of local Italian wine. For a starter, why not order the sardines with bread and butter? Simple yet delicious, this dish beautifully combines the sourness of the sardines with the buttery-smoothness of the bread. The agnolotti—ravioli filled with ricotta and Parmigiano Re
Osteria 106
Italian restaurant · Upper West Side
Visiting Osteria 106 is like taking a trip to Italy. Tucked away in a relaxed neighborhood, the restaurant greets guests with its cozy atmosphere and mouth-watering smells. The menu offers a variety of Italian dishes, from the classic Spaghetti alle Vongole to the modern Foie Gras Ravioli. Even the most discerning diner will find something to suit their taste. The chefs craft each dish with finesse, using the freshest ingredients to guarantee a delicious, flavorful experience. The service is also incredibly attentive, with staff greeting guests with a smile as soon as they enter. The waiters take the time to answer any questions and explain the menu, creating an informal atmosphere that feels like dining with family rather than strangers. The entire experience was pleasant and enjoyable. Overall, Osteria 106 is an excellent restaurant that offers authentic Italian cuisine and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. It is the perfect destination for a romantic evening
Il Corso
Italian restaurant · Midtown West
Il Corso, nestled in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, is a local favorite and an oasis of Italian fine dining. The restaurant's relaxed and inviting atmosphere offers a truly unique and pleasurable experience, making it a staple for returning guests who come back month after month. The cuisine draws upon the best ingredients and flavors that Italy has to offer. The menu features a delectable selection of pastas and appetizers, each crafted with skill and attention to detail. The gnocchi, prepared with fresh tomatoes and a hearty bolognese, is a generous portion and sure to satisfy any palette. The spaghetti, though a bit small, is beautifully balanced with fresh veggies and herbs that make it a wonderful experience. The Ceasar salad, although a special addition, is definitely worth trying. As it is located withing easy reach of Carnegie Hall, Il Corso is the perfect place to go before a show, and with friendly staff and good service
Risotteria Melotti NYC
Italian restaurant · East Village
Risotteria Melotti NYC is the perfect place for an authentic Italian dining experience. Situated in the trendy East Village in Manhattan, this restaurant offers something for everyone. The gastronomic highlight is of course the incredible selection of delicious and unique risottos on the menu. All dishes are crafted with the freshest ingredients, bringing out the full flavour of the Italian cuisine. The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and inviting. The friendly staff makes sure to provide a great dining experience for customers. While the prices for dishes are slightly higher than most restaurants in the area, the quality of the food and ingredients are second to none. For those looking for a genuinely Italian experience, Risotteria Melotti NYC is the place to go. With its mouth-watering risotto selection, friendly and attentive staff, and charming atmosphere, it promises a delightful—and memorable—dining experience.
IL Punto
Italian restaurant · Hell's Kitchen
Il Punto is a small and quaint Italian restaurant located in the heart of New York City. The warm and welcoming atmosphere provides a family style service feel that one can't help but appreciate. The menu consists of traditional Italian dishes cooked with flavourful recipes that have been passed down from generations. The quality of the food at Il Punto is top notch. From the Antipasti to the handmade Tiramisu, every dish is cooked to perfection with a unique twist. Not to be missed is the house special Pistachio Tiramisu which melts in the mouth and lingers with its delicious flavour. The Ice Cream Salad is an inventive way to enjoy Italian desserts that is sure to please even the most discerning palates. The staff at Il Punto delivers a special kind of attentive service that is truly appreciated. On one particularly busy night, the host Jim was especially patient and kind. He ensured that every guest was well looked after and left the restaurant
Maestro Pasta
Italian restaurant · Greenwich Village
Maestro Pasta is a perfect ten. Delicious and flavourful richness, refined presentation and freshness is what comes with every dish. The atmosphere replicates that of a high-class restaurant, right in the heart of the downtown neighbourhood. The star of the show at Maestro Pasta is that of their homemade pasta. Cooked to perfection, it offers a distinct taste compared to any other pasta dish in the city. Maestro Pasta's whole pasta-making process is on display, inspiring guests to discover the renowned flavours of their Italian cuisine. When it comes to comfort Italian food, Maestro pasta is the go-to spot. Each bite is full of taste, rarely can a forkful of pasta be savoured as it is at Maestro. All the ingredients are well-sourced, complemented with their signature pasta that leaves guests coming for more. Simply put, Maestro Pasta not only leaves you feeling satisfied, but is