Wanda's Pie in the Sky

Charming little spot with some really tasty pies. The crust was perfect and the filling hit the spot. A bit pricey for what it is, but still worth it for the quality. Definitely a nice place to stop by if you're in the mood for something sweet.

I had a slice of the key lime and it was really great. The inside was cozy and I loved the piano. Brought home a coconut cream pie for my grandmother and she was very happy with it, she said it was some of the best pie she’s had. Cherry pie was not my favourite as it tastes a bit medicinal to me, but I feel that way about most cherry-flavoured things. Blueberry cheesecake was also good. A very nice experience overall!

Wanda's Pie in the Sky is a delightful bakery known for its homemade pies and charming atmosphere. **Food:** The pies are the star of the show, with a wide variety of flavors ranging from classic fruit pies like apple and blueberry to unique options like chocolate pecan and key lime. The crusts are buttery and flaky, and you can often find delicious seasonal options. They also offer cakes, cookies, and other baked goods that are equally tempting. **Atmosphere:** The bakery has a cozy, welcoming vibe, making it a great spot to relax with a slice of pie or grab a treat to go. The decor is charming and adds to the overall experience. **Service:** The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, happy to help you choose the perfect pie or dessert. They create a warm environment that makes you feel right at home. **Value:** Prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality and portion sizes. It’s a great place to indulge without feeling like you’re overspending. **Overall Experience:** Wanda's Pie in the Sky is a must-visit for pie lovers and anyone with a sweet tooth. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick treat or looking to order a pie for a special occasion, you’re in for a delicious experience!

It's been 2 months since I visited this spot and I still long to go back here. Probably the best slice of pie I've had in my entire life. I ordered slices of both the coconut cream pie and the apple pie. The apple pie was amazing and very rustic, but the coconut cream pie was just something else. I've never been a huge fan of coconut but this slice made me want to try more coconut flavoured dishes. The service here was also amazing - very friendly and welcoming staff who was ready to help & offer her suggestions. What I wouldn't give to return here!

Really cute pie spot in Kensington, we tried the Apple and Banana Cream. I found the Apple pie to be a bit too sweet for me but I know lots of people enjoy that. The banana cream pie was good, it felt like a lot more cream than banana content though.

My gf knew I really liked lemon meringue and key lime pie so for my bday she researched to find a place and found this place which happens to specializes in pies. I took a look on the website beforehand and the pictures looked BUENO (thank God they have pictures too). We stopped by after filling our tummies with some goodies over at St Lawrence Market, while making sure to leave enough room. So did it live up to the hype? The lemon meringue pie? Not so much. The key lime pie? ABSOLUTELY. Wow. Will DEFINITELY be coming back for more key lime pie. Amazing pie slice. The lemon meringue slice, while the curd was tasty, it could've used less thickener imo. The meringue I could tell had been sitting maybe a lil too long cuz it was already leaking a slight bit of water. I think my mom can make a comparable lemon meringue (possibly even a better one). I do want to come back though. The peach melba sounds incredible. I also saw someone get an apple crumble slice and it looked really good too so I want to try apple crumble as well. They should provide an ice cream scoop add-on option for some of their pie slices (maybe not during winter but during summer!) We got a cup of hot apple cider to wash everything down. It was ok. Definitely not as good as the apple cider we had at Applewood Farms over in Stouffville, but that's to be expected I guess. 100% coming back. I don't think any key lime pie I've had comes close.

Best pie in the city! Been coming here for years. Favourite is key lime 🤤 But banana pie is also very good. I used to love pecan and chocolate pecan pie but now I can't handle that much sugar but it's one of their popular ones. Please bring back chocolate peanut butter tho. I haven't seen that one years 🥹

Excellent pies probably best I've had in the city. Apple crumble and strawberry rhubarb were both perfect. Taste like I imagined the pies in the cartoons would taste like cooling down on the windows as a child. The staff were friendly. There is no table service. The location is cool and fun. Only complaint is that they had a bunch of wasps in the place and on the pies which is both annoying and not very hygienic.