Upside Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Nolita

Upside Pizza

Pizza restaurant · Nolita

5

51 Spring St, New York, NY 10012

Photos

Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by Alex Staniloff
Upside Pizza by Infatuation - Reviews
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null
Upside Pizza by null

Highlights

This chill spot serves up incredible pizzas with homemade mozzarella, featuring a standout pepperoni slice that’s hot, crispy, and perfectly balanced.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater

51 Spring St, New York, NY 10012 Get directions

upsidepizza.com
@upsidepizza

$$$$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

51 Spring St, New York, NY 10012 Get directions

+1 917 409 2989
upsidepizza.com
@upsidepizza
𝕏
@upsidepizza

$$$$$ · Menu

Features

dine in
takeout
delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations
outdoor seating

Last updated

Feb 19, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"After trying Upside’s cheese slice from their new Soho location that’s made with sourdough, we might be ready to say goodbye to Joe’s as our de facto NYC slice recommendation. The dough from Upside is noticeably tangy, the cheese stays put, and there are patches of bubbly caramelized cheese that make us thankful for fire. The square slices shouldn’t be missed, especially their cheese-less Sicilian that’s covered in thin slices of garlic, crisped up basil leaves, and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce that’s zesty and not too sweet." - Carlo Mantuano

Upside Pizza - Review - Soho - New York - The Infatuation
test
@eater

"Upside Pizza is expanding into Pomodoro Pizzeria’s old spot in Little Italy." - Erika Adams

NYC Restaurant and Bars’ 10 Percent COVID Surcharge Goes Into Effect - Eater NY
test
@infatuation

"Outsider is a slice cart that someone stuck on the side of the road at Beacon Hill Station, and while they used to bake up fantastic personal pies topped with charred dough bubbles and freshly grated pecorino romano, things have changed since then. It's now a by-the-slice operation that serves pretty lackluster New York-style pizza. Nothing's overwhelmingly terrible about it, but much like slices you'd find at an airport kiosk (you know the ones, with names like "Via Piazza" or "Mamma Mia"), the sauce is overseasoned, there's too much cheese, and the crust doesn't have any flavor or bready chew. If you're in the neighborhood and are desperate for pizza, go to Bar Del Corso instead." - Aimee Rizzo

Outsider Pizza Review - Beacon Hill - Seattle - The Infatuation
test
@davidcho

A good place to go for a slice with less problematic ownership.

Some Places for Serena's Cousin
test
@karolynpho
New York Food
test

ii G

Google
Delicious, fast and if you compare to joes pizzazz… this place is SUPERIOR in taste quality PRICE and vibe. The staff was so sweet and quick, pizza dough was thin but had a delicious flavor. We even ate the crust! tried the white wine, mushroom, the tiny NY pepperonis were delicious and the whole experience was so excellent. You guys really need to try Upside pizza. My parents went back twice after because they just loved it. The street smells delicious and that’s how we stumbled on here!!! Price point was great. We got 6 slices and two drinks for $28 😊

Crz “A”

Google
Stumbled upon this pizza place 😋. Had a pepperoni slice. was great. Thin, right amount of sauce, lots of pepperoni slices, and they made it hot (temperature). Love Loveeee when a pizza is hot 🔥. August 2024 and a pepperonslicr was $5.00. Service is fast and on point. There is seating inside and outside. You can pay with card / Android Pay / Apple Pay.

Raghav Grover

Google
An absolute 9.2 on the Dave Portnoy scale! The cheese slice is legendary - no flop, great leopard spotting on the undercarriage and optimal sauce and cheese ratio. It hits all the marks and is a nice light and crispy slice.

Marc S

Google
Their mushroom WWLC slice is the best hidden gem in the city. I have no idea why more people don’t talk about it. Highly recommended!!!

NY chinchilla

Google
Such great pizza. My favorite was the mushroom with white wine. Very tasty!

Kevin Mastro

Google
I have no photos bc I ate it too fast. Ready to come back for another vodka slice and some knots. Divine.

ml

Google
Solid slice of pepperoni pizza. The pepperoni s were cuppy, and nice char to the dough. Good spot for a quick bite while browsing the shops in the neighborhood

D S

Google
A really good classic margarita slice. Crust is good and flavours are well balanced.

Yan T.

Yelp
As much as I wanted to dislike Upside, these uppity newcomers have won me over with their sourdough crust and fresh-made mozzarella. As a fun fact, these are the same guys who own 2 Bros Pizza, the cheap slice chain. But they are also pumping out IG-quality, artisanal pies (at more artisanal prices) in at least 2 locations in Manhattan. The crust is very solid and the dough works surprisingly well on a NY pie. It immediately became one of our top 5 pizza places in NYC and my son's and wife's overall favorites.

Kerlin M.

Yelp
It was quick service. I didn't like my pizza very much though, mushroom seemed a bit old. It was unbearable greasy. My girlfriend didn't like her cheese pizza either. What saved them is they at least happen to have way more seating options (although still very limited). I also gave them another point for having coke in a glass bottle - which we all know makes it 10 times better. In all - I would AVOID getting pizza here. Definitely better places to try

Danielle P.

Yelp
After trying and failing to get a reservation at Rubirosa, we passed by this pizza place that looked pretty good so we decided to grab a slice to split while figuring out what we were actually going to do for dinner. In retrospect, we could've just had slices here and call it a day. Upside is a pretty casual pizza counter spot where most people are ordering slices to go, with some table space for those who want to scarf their slices down while it's hot. It was busy but not impossible to grab a table, we ended up opting for one outside since it was one of those unseasonably warm days. They have both square and round pizza here, but the square slices seem to be their thing. Big, fluffy, and crispy, we decided to just get a standard Sicilian which did not disappoint. Good sauce to cheese ratio, and the crunch on these slices could probably be heard down the block. A solid slice option if you're in the area.

Mechet N.

Yelp
We spent the day walking and stopped in about 10 places for the perfect pizza slice. If you're looking for the best slice in New York City look no further! Upside pizza is by far the best pizza hands down. Crisp, light and delicious! The perfect sauce to cheese ratio and the dough was crispy and light. Their vodka pizza is by far the best !!!!

Erin M.

Yelp
While I came to visit New York, I was always told to come try the pizza, and this place did not disappoint. Even before going inside I can smell the pizza outside and had to try. It was crowded but I did come during the weekend and thankfully was able to find seats. They were a bit messy inside but with how busy and crowded it was, it was not surprising. The pizza on the window looked good and fluffy but only wanted a pepperoni slice. The guys there took my order and was able to get my food somewhat quick. At first the pizza itself didn't look impressive and was greasy but was a huge slice. Once I picked it up and started to eat, I was actually surprised that it tasted good. The crust held up well so wasn't flopping all over like I expected. The crust was good too and had a good crunch. I like how the sauce was light and good amount of cheese for sure. It was greasy too but not overwhelming. I would definitely come back here again if I'm in New York in the future.

Evan N.

Yelp
I mean the pizza itself was just okay. They both were just lacking a ton of seasoning and flavor. The vodka slice tasted nothing like vodka sauce and the mushroom and wine pizza just tasted like pizza. The crusts were very inconsistent as some were honestly pretty decent and others were just tough. Also some of them weren't even heated properly as our slices were not fully warmed. With so many pizza options in the area I just don't see myself coming back. It's a slice shop so the service is quick.

Shirin B.

Yelp
Didn't expect to encounter one of the best pizza shops in the city today! Upside pizza is so good and if you go at a decent time the line isn't too bad and it moves quick. Get a slice of pep or the mushroom with lemon cream sauce which was so delicious and crispy and hot and perfectly thin and so much flavor! Right after, stop by soft side to get some ice cream and a lactaid pill!

Andrew M.

Yelp
It's a solid place for a late-night slice. The staff was very nice and accommodating.

JP P.

Yelp
This place is always busy but the pie is pretty decent! There's a guy behind the counter who is rude AF. Other than that I will say that management / owners(?) are very attentive and kind. The spicy vodka slice is a star! 4.5 out of 5 The garlic knots are pretty good but they need to give more sauce. Overall, I go here each time I'm in the area and want a quick slice.

Emely F.

Yelp
Great crispy thin pizza. Tomato sauce is nice and tangy. The cheese to sauce ratio was great. Pepperonis were curled and crisped to perfection. Service is quick and efficient.The design is unique with the red and white color-way. Definitely looking forward to going back.

Cole D.

Yelp
Delicious sourdough pizza! I expected a little more flavor but overall good. I don't know many sourdough places in the city so I was really excited to try this place. The mushroom white wine slice was delicious. Just the name made me mouth salivate. It's a little dry of a slice so a little moisture could help take it to the next level.

Connie H.

Yelp
I went to run with my friends and was told there'd be pizza after, so I ended up here! + $6 for the thicker squares and $5 for the slices. + They sell beers and other drinks too + Quick service given our group + Feels like a grab and go spot but there is some indoor seating + Playlist was defo a vibe when we were there Overall, nice spot for some late night pizza.

Helen S.

Yelp
Only a couple people in line when we went late afternoon on a weekend but all the seats inside taken and many people standing around to eat their pizza and garlic knots. Thankfully we snagged a seat and really enjoyed our sausage and pepper pizza and mushroom lemon pizza, divine! Nice thin crust type of pizza, not too dense or heavy.

Honor G.

Yelp
Pros Busy pizza shop Delicious pizza Inside& outdoor seating Quick service Awesome music playlist Great location for people watching Trendy & busy location Close to trains Close to multiple shops Dr. Pepper as beverage option Frozen yogurt next door Cons Zero

Iris H.

Yelp
Nice atmosphere and a good location near SOHO to grab a quick slice of pizza. Crust is crispy and thin which I like. But everything else is mid. It's kinda dry but it's not bad... just not any "wow" delicious factor. The roll is also overcooked and tastes not as fluffy as I thought.

Anisha A.

Yelp
Soooo good I'll be back- I like it more than prince st pizza around the corner, highly recommend. Cheaper too $5 a slice

Michael C.

Yelp
We stopped by for a quick slice while in the area. We just got a classic pepperoni slice, and it was decent. The crust had too much gluten development, so it was too chewy; it felt like I was getting a jaw workout. It did have a good crisp to it though! The pizza was also overall too salty, which drowned out some of the other flavors, such as the pizza sauce and the pepperoni itself. Overall, decent. If ever in the area and wanting a slice, wouldn't hesitate to stop by!

Aidan M.

Yelp
Great find, small spot but great pizza. Spicy Vodka was great I'll be back! Service was quick and friendly

Aidan C.

Yelp
Pizza was great and seating area was clean and comfy! Service was friendly and fast. This place was just splendid! I almost fell over from pleasure at the first bite.

Mason _.

Yelp
Italians are truly a wonder of the modern world, specifically the Italians in NYC, their culture gets me all hyped up and in the moment. This being said, I skipped all of that and went to the pizza shop next to the Street wide Festival of Saint Genaro. The exterior was really inviting and fit well on the corner of the street and I had to try New York pizza because everyone loves a good cliche no? I've never been a big fan of slice style pizza joints because you can't customize that jahn to your liking but I'd have to ignore that. Today's review will include a bit of human error, this being due to me having to ignore my hatred of marinara. Fock that red ah sauce. I ordered a slice of pepperoni and a Sicilian slice of the same topping. At first taste I didn't get enough of the Pep and cheese combo but when I learned to hold the cheese instead of ripping it out with my pearly whites. This made the experience so much better and is what pushed this review from three to four stars. That pepperoni was something else. This stuff always comes in clutch, America runs on pizza. I love pizza.

K C.

Yelp
Quintessential New York Street slice! At the midtown location the slice was the best pizza I had in this trip, at this location I preferred the slice. Nearly as good as Prince street. The edge here was caramelized with cheese like a Detroit square and every bit as goods crunched liked a stale piece of toast but in a good way. I can't wait to come back!

Gab G.

Yelp
Amazing pizza option in what can otherwise be a very annoying food area (in terms of most everything being sit-down). I tried a vodka slice, which was incredible, and a pepperoni square, which was also great. Will definitely be back.

Beckie S.

Yelp
This pizza is so good I can't stop coming back I'm obsessed. Crispy, hot, and fresh!!!!!!!!!

Jane D.

Yelp
Upside Pizza opened to a lot of fanfare. I've frequented the location by the Port Authority and others around the city. This Soho adjacent locale was reliable as a post-drinks spot when Prince Street was either closed or you didn't want to deal with lines. Writing this to say- AVOID. This is the worst pizza I have eaten as a native New Yorker. The Sicilian was burnt with large "scabs" of congealed cheese and the veg slice (surprise!) came with chunks of meat and was so salty and so garlicky that it completely assaulted my taste buds and led to so much indigestion that I did not sleep all night. The dough was like flavorless cardboard and as thick as a pizza box lid flap. Truly the most regrettable pizza ever I have ever purchased. Domestic pizza I have eaten thousands of miles away from New York has been better than what I was served last night. In the past cheese and pepperoni slices have been reliable here and I've tried some truly exceptional flavors at the original location so this place was a solid 3-4 stars, however, whoever was making the pizza (or reheating old pizza) at the NoLiTa location around 8:30pm on Nov. 8, 2024 needs to find a new career path.

Jeff O.

Yelp
Upside is a newish pizza purveyor that has four locations around town and is very much in the vanguard of NYC's slice-joint renaissance, which is flourishing to such a degree that it's getting hard to keep track of all the spots serving up impressive versions of our city's most famous and essential comestible. This location in Nolita is, as you'd expect, ridiculously stylish for a pizza parlor, with contemporary wood paneling, mosaic and checkerboard tiles, and an overall aesthetic that possibly drew inspiration from a Scandinavian interior designer. And for such a pretty place in Nolita it is also, as you'd expect, not inexpensive -- most slices are $5, i.e., roughly the same as an entire medium pizza at some chain like Domino's or Little Caesar's, or five times what you'll pay if you can find an increasingly rare dollar slice anywhere in 2024. Aside from the location and decor, the steep price point probably reflects quality ingredients, e.g., parmigiano reggiano and good olive oil, which really do result in slices that are lip-smackingly tasty. Also, the crust is technically impressive; regular slices are foldable without being floppy, and Sicilian squares are unusually puffy and light, reminiscent of the delicate oblong wonders at the dearly departed Corner Slice inside Gotham West Market. So, overall, Upside is among the spendier slices in town, but you do get what you pay for.

Aagdolla G.

Yelp
I definitely reccomend. Taste was sharp and I enjoyed every bit of it. They allow you to add Parmesan cheese powder that's around the shop for everyone. The pizza is thin and after I ate one slice it felt like I didn't eat anything lol or maybe I was just really hungry idk.

Angie W.

Yelp
Great quick slice of pizza to grab while walking around DT. It's always reliable and ready to go!

Pete L.

Yelp
Wow. One of the top NY pizza spots. The sauce made this pizza what it is. The light char of the bottom of the pizza was the perfect texture. Had the pepperoni which was amazing. Limited seating area. Very personable workers who take pride in what they do. Will def come back to try the other slices.

Truc T.

Yelp
Went in for a quick slice, came out finding happiness can be found at Pizza Parlors. I wish I remembered the name of the slice I got, but this was the best mushroom cheese slice I've had in a very long time as a pizza fan. The taste reminded me of Crème fraîche(fresh cream) mushrooms over beautifully baked dough. How can something be so thin, yet so full of flavor. What makes New York great are places like Upside Pizza. Whether you're a college student, executive, parent, dog, your grandma's goldfish, or having a bad day, for a couple bucks, an amazing slice can lift up your day! Till next time Upside Pizza!

Elle D.

Yelp
This is the best pizza I've ever had. I got a slice of spicy vodka, very quick and relatively cheap.

Jeremy D.

Yelp
This is very good pizza. Great for a quick slice and decent seating. Spicy vodka is excellent.

Zach O.

Yelp
Alright, so this may be a hot take, but Upside Pizza is low key one of the better pizza places in NYC. I consider it a hot take because when I was doing my research for the best pizza places, Upside was hardly mentioned. Sure it wasn't the best pizza I had in the city, but it was definitely up there. A very underrated place that deserves more love! I highly recommend checking it out when you're in the area!

Diane T.

Yelp
Grabbed a thick square and a regular Margaret slice, , I would have liked more sauce, but they were very good. Quick service w good variety to choose from. Found an open table, buthad to clean it ourselves-that seems normal in NYC. Good slices/ but not in the top 10 for me.

Rachel B.

Yelp
I wish I had 2 stomachs to try all The flavors of Pizza they had but I stuck with the tried and true pepperoni which was DEER-LISH-SHHHUUSSS!! It's a thin yet thick Slice With zesty Marina and Plenty of cheese but thin pepperonis That are small but manageable. A slice Is about $5.50. Next time I will try the sausage, mushroom and broccoli rabe!! Tables inside have have ample breeze but there are also spacious tables outside. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was cuz the crusts were super dry and hard, and the slice was really oily. Still would come back!!

Jessie H.

Yelp
This place is decent pizza. Nothing amazing, but I appreciated the shortish, fast moving line.

Jeffrey G.

Yelp
Upside is more of tourist spot to me which I didn't like at first. The pepperoni slice had too much flavor and came off salty to me. The sausage and peppers is my go to order but I like how the service is consistent here. You arrive order and they start heating up your slice right away. I like the overall aesthetic of Upside.

Matthew S.

Yelp
I feel good. Today I experienced a life changing event, so I am perhaps a bit bouncy, and it will reflect in this review. Upside Pizza is a pizza joint I have been meaning to try. It has been on my list, my radar, for several months, and each time I seem to never find the time to try the slices out. I finally got the chance today. The slices come out hot, and incredibly crispy. It is a great crust, a rather thin one, but I liked the taste. There was little burn on the undercarriage, it had a nice blonde color, not raw at all. The cheese is undoubtedly the star here. It is super fresh and full of flavor. The grease just pours out the slices, like pools of grease (it is really excess cheese), just ooze out. Unfortunately, the sauce is kinda bland and the power of the cheese is simply too much. I would also suggest trying their Spicy Vodka slice. It is not too overwhelming in spice, but has good flavor and complements most of the slices in the pizzeria. It is also super close to the Spring St subway station on the 6 train. Normally, I would restrain on this pie and say it is a 3.8/5, but I'll be nicer and say 3.9. I have gone back and forth on giving it the 4 point rating but unfortunately I have to keep it where it is at 3.9. Now therefore go.

Danny N.

Yelp
Next time I want a slice I'm flying here idc, unreal food man. Look at that shine, look at the crusttttt!

Mike H.

Yelp
The office catered from here with a variety of pies. I had the spicy vodka pizza and the tomato pie which was focaccia with sauce. The focaccia was very good, and the sauce was SO flavorful. There was an explosion of flavor when I tasted the sauce. 10/10, and I don't give those out lightly. The spicy vodka sauce slice was good but nothing special. A bit too oily but satisfying.

Geo M.

Yelp
Good pizza by the slice. Sourdough based crust. I ordered a cheese pie the night before I went home back to Cali and brought to my daughter. Traveled well and was just as delicious after being warmed up! NYC Pizza

Kaya E.

Yelp
Popped into Upside Pizza while doing some shopping in Soho. This spot is definitely a more upscale pizzeria with it's nice design touches. On a Sunday afternoon this place was packed with all seating on the inside and outside in use. Luckily I planned to just grab and go so I was happy that the service was fairly quick. I ordered 2 cheese slices which came out to $8... a bit pricey for my taste but for a good slice I'll do it. When I bit into the pizza it was way too crispy, you could barely fold the crust and the sauce lacked flavor. I'm not sure I'll be back here but it did get the job done. ...Back to my journey of finding the perfect slice

Nico D.

Yelp
This is the worst slice of pizza I have tasted in New York City. I got a Sicilian pepperoni slice. The sauce and cheese and crust is terrible. Staff is nice.

Al H.

Yelp
Very good slice. If you like it extra crispy, it has a good amount of crunch. What really reeled ne in was that they were playing some mellow Bob Marley tunes.

Alan N.

Yelp
Standard slice. Not the best but serviceable. This place gets popular especially since it's by a touristy area and soho.

Bruce K.

Yelp
A slice on the hoof, I saw it at the counter, they popped it in the oven for two minutes and then it was on a plate. Ready to go and I walked and at my way to the next stop. The pizza was a little thin, but well topped. Tasty with a spicy pepperoni on it and just a little bit of grease that dripped onto the streets of Manhattan. [Review 18381 overall - 379 in New York - 1903 of 2022.]

Samantha D.

Yelp
Came here for a lighter bite in the middle of the day. I got a tomato slice. The tomato sauce was too acidic for me. However the crust and bread were so good. A good amount of heft yet still so crispy. The aromatics of the garlic and basil were fragrant. There's ample amount of seating. However, I can see it getting busy. Definitely would want to come back to try a normal slice sometime.

Simone O.

Yelp
I came here just walking by after a party at a bar nearby and the staff was incredibly rude to us. My friends just sat down at the beer area, just wanting to find a place to sit, while I waited in line and the servers told them to get out because it was not a bar, but they weren't intending to get a drink. They then proceeded to kick them out of the store while I waited in line to order some garlic knots, which we got about 6 of them and they were pretty good, but not happy about the way the staff talked to us. Maybe it's just a late night New York thing ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Hayward L.

Yelp
Upscale, renovated pizza spot that's popular with the late night crowd. Pizzas are solid but not that special. Then again, when you've had a few drinks you just want a hot slice in your mouth quickly and this place delivers. Their pepperoni squares are decent but generally inferior to Prince Street Pizza around the corner. Some of the pizzas get left in the oven for too long when they're being reheated and tasted burnt. For around $5 a slice, there are better spots nearby but overall this is a convenient, casual spot that does the basics.

Shawn S.

Yelp
Super good. Crust does not flop. Sauce is nice and the toppings are good. Good music :)