The Pie Pizzeria - Underground

Hidden gem! In such an amazing location and the environment is very exciting and gives you that New York feel! I’ve gone here with my kids since they were little and it’s awesome to see it hasn’t changed. Love all the drawings on the wall and the cool pictures they have hanging.

So I’ve been to the pie many times and up til recently I would rate it 4-5 stars no problem. Tonight when we went we ordered the Buffalo Chicken Ranch pizza, which we have ordered regularly and never received it so greasy. I never have complained and am the type to avoid making complaints but in this case we asked the person who took our order if they would take it back or remake it and they said “that’s just how that pizza is” and refused to work with us. In the past this pizza was not literally soggy from grease. We did not even finish a slice each and left the pizza at our table. Based on the service the past two visits we have made I unfortunately would not recommend the pie.

Virtually all the tables were cluttered and not cleared throughout the entire restaurant. Staff could seem to care less about the fact there was no place to sit and no bus trays or trash receptacles to clear it on your own. We cleared the table shown by moving all our dishes to another table that had not been serviced. Not likely to go back, even though the pizza was excellent.

This place was awesome! I have family who is always visiting from California and looking for good pizza places. This one has awesome ratings and is open Sundays and serves beer so it's like a triple bonus for us today. Got a couple pies and some drinks and it did not disappoint. The whole vibe of the place is super chill and relaxed. We really enjoyed our time and the pizza filled up so good! Will definitely come back if we are in the area!

We discovered this place a few years ago on a road trip. This time around, we purposely took a detour and added a couple hours to our trip so we could eat here. Absolutely amazing pizza. We tried the thai wings as well and they were a blast. We surely visit again when we get a chance.

One of the best local pizzerias in Salt Lake. I'm not sure if it is a good or a bad thing that is within walking distance! If there's a line, it's worth the wait. The atmosphere is great and brings back those nostalgic memories of the Pizza Hut of my youth (only tastes better and supports a local business). There's also a decent selection of beer on tap at a decent price.

Hadn't visited the Pie since high school. It's just as amazing as I remembered. And even better because they have cauliflower crust AND gluten free bread sticks. So good! I ordered the Greek (minus tomatoes), my husband loves the Wise Guy. We definitely left STUFFED. And it was the perfect time to visit, with College out for the semester.

This pizza place was definitely interesting. It’s a whole vibe inside! The pull apart was the all around favorite! The pizzas were all extremely cheesy. Sauce tasted great. We didn’t get to try the dessert pizzas because they forgot to put them in & after we waited 20 minutes, we got a refund. My one, and biggest, complaint is that the seating area is not really made for large parties- which there were so many when we went! We had to shove several tables together for our party of 11 people. We were also surrounded by others having to do the same so we were pretty tightly shoved in one corner of the restaurant.