Scott T.
Yelp
Probably the classiest bar I will ever go to.
Kishi-san - considered one of the "godfathers" of Japanese bartending - was generous and kind. The staff was polite and friendly. The venue is stunning on the outside, and quietly exudes an old school opulence on the inside. Whether this sounds good or bad to you, the phrase "they don't make them like this anymore" definitely seems apt here.
I read through some of the negative reviews, just out of surprise and curiosity, and acknowledge that some of things described in them, e.g. mercurial service or having to inhale cigarette smoke, sound legitimately off-putting. I suppose I got lucky, because I didn't experience any of that. In fact, quite the opposite.
On the night I walked in, there were a trio of tourists shouting and laughing loudly at the bar, oblivious to how much they were disturbing everyone else. The young girl kept mentioning pointedly that she was from Shanghai, apparently not realizing that was not having the effect she seemed to expect on those around her.
As soon as a table opened up in the corner of the bar, the staff asked the group politely if they'd like to move there, which they enthusiastically agreed to do. They may have assumed they were getting better treatment, but overhearing the staff in Japanese definitely confirmed it was more to spare the rest of us at the bar. Class can't be bought, but it can be taught.
Thankfully after another ten minutes, the group drunkenly stumbled out, leaving the rest of the bar to enjoy ourselves in peace. The rest of my night unfolded smoothly.
I highly recommend Star Bar if you're in Tokyo and looking for an intimate, stately place to have a drink. They also have a location in Kyoto.