Solly's Grille

Peno burger (normal butter, lettuce, tomato) 5.6/10 Sassy Burger (normal butter) 4.5/10 Vanilla milkshake (8.6/10) Fries 4.5/10 Note to self. Ask for extra light butter or no butter. A normal amount of butter is a quarter cup of high quality Wisconsin butter that melts into the hot patty leaving your burger marinating in a shallow hot tub of liquid butter. It's just a bit too much butter and made me feel a little nauseous after ingesting the whole thing. I will still give the other burgers a try on my return visit

Awesome burger place, with a lot of very cool history! Been in business since 1936. The food was great, the atmosphere was nice, the staff was awesome! My waitress was Mulanda, and she was wonderful! Very nice, and knew a lot of the history. It was certainly a pleasure meeting her! I will definitely be back for the Big Boy burger, the original I had today was great, but the big boy is next on the list!

Classic greasy spoon restaurant with the best butter burgers, smashed and fried to perfection. I'll have to try other menu items one day, but it so hard not to not have their burgers. The place is usually packed as seating is limited. Lots of regulars for breakfast and lunch. Cash only.

Finally got the chance to try this place and came in for lunch. It was about 30 past noon. I order the Big Boy burger. It came with kringles fries. Fries came out first. I like kringle fries. Then the Big Boy came out. This was like a premium Big Mac burger. Taste 100% on point. It was juicy and buttery. Definitely one of the better burgers I ate in the Milwaukee area. The only thing was this was a premium burger with a premium price. Almost $20. Good to try at least once. Would I buy it again? Eh?!! Not for the price. But I would try a different burger.

A charming local place, we came for the butter burgers but were a little taken aback by the quantity of butter on the burger. We made some adjustments for our personal tastes and enjoyed the burger and sweet potato fries. We got a rootbeer float and chocolate milkshake, which was quite a treat, prepared old school style and presented with the mid 20th century trade mark silver metallic "malt" cup.

First time in Milwaukee and my 1st time trying a Butter Burger. I was super scared at 1st, but after talking to the waitress and she explained how to order, the sizes, the local favorites, and walking me through the menu - I was ready to order. I had the 1/3 lb burger with sweet potato fries. It was absolutely delicious 😋 - honestly and no exaggeration - this was the best burger I have ever tasted. Literally, my mind was blown; something so simple looking would be so darn delicious.

Nice atmosphere of a diner setting. However the counter stools were too close for comfort, no elbow room. Our server was great, polite and friendly. From what I observed all the staff was great. As far as the food it was a good burger but I have had better beef burgers. The butter was a bit much, I can see a buttered bun, but it was swimming in butter. I almost choked on the butter. We paid around $52 for 2 cheeseburgers a patty melt one med fry and 2 sodas. A bit over priced but I am glad we got to try it, however I'm not sure if we will go back.

Came here with the family to get a quick lunch and it was an absolute delight! The staff here are super friendly and really made me kids feel comfortable and laugh. My daughter has a peanut allergy and they were super chill about it here and attentive. The cheese butter burger is incredible and the fries as well! Highly recommend and we'll definitely be coming back!