Prison Street Pizza

Delicious! So much flavor and perfect texture! My wife and I got the Old World Pizza with pepperoni. It went well with a couple of Maui beers and a side Ceasar salad. The staff are great, really chill crew. There's neat outdoor seating (you cannot drink alcoholic beverages outside). It's a good vibe. We paid about $25 a person with a good tip. They make by the slice too.

Very little seating. The service was good, very friendly. The garlic cheese bread was very garlicky but not so cheesy. This is a traditional jersey thin crust and you can't get it any other way, not that that is a bad thing, just something to keep in mind. A pizza is what you make of it, by that I mean you are the one choosing the toppings so choose wisely.

This is the exact type of pizza I'm always looking for. Crispy crust, great sauce or cheese ratio and delicious flavor. Reasonable prices, cute place and excellent service.

Needed a quick bite to eat before a boat ride, and Prison Street Pizza was the perfect option for us! Being from the East Coast originally, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality and taste of the pizza! It was very affordable, quick, and delicious. And the staff was super friendly and nice -- they even gave us some fresh mango from their property for a free dessert! Thank you.

Pizza was yummy, just not a fan of the crust but their toppings were pretty good. Nice ambiance and very friendly staff. They close pretty early so check their hours before you go.

I was definitely ready to try pizza again on this trip back to Maui. This time we were looking for a good thin crust. Prison Street Pizza the highest reviews on Google and list a thin crust Jersey style pizza. We decided to try 2 styles of topping - one of course being Hawaiian and the other being cheese on one side and pepperoni and mushroom on the other. Those pizzas are really good the only problem is they suffer what a lot of larger thin crusts do where they're pretty soggy towards the center. The crusts are really good and crispy ...just ran into a little bit of doughiness or sogginess towards the center of the pizza. Overall I would say this in a top notch pizza and absolutely Worth to stop by if you're in Maui. Add in the fact that we got two medium sized pizzas with a lot of toppings for under $40 that's a heck of a value on this island

Super friendly and fast service. We were there after a lunch rush so was easy finding a table. I highly recommend their Pizza. We tried a medium vegetable pizza but I recommend the large for only few more dollars. Loved the local beer selection also. I tried the Brew from Hilo, Hawaii. Our server was really friendly and cool. Left an extra tip since they gave great service and food effortless! Cannot wait to try their new restaurant up country!! Much Aloha! I love NY style!

I rarely give bad reviews here but as a local in Lahaina town this place has been a big disappointment. Today is my husbands birthday and all he wanted to do is to relax and have a nice pizza for dinner. In the last few times we ordered here our order did not come as expected. Tonight was the last straw. We got there plenty of time for pickup. My husband still stood in line for 10mins which was understandable but when we got home our pizza was burnt and very dry. The Serpico pizza had some burnt spots on the bottom and extremely very dry. The Freight Train pizza supposed to have some BBQ sauce but instead all we can taste was the pork and the crust was burnt all over and very dry. We are all for supporting our local restaurants and understand that most of them struggles from shortage of staffs and with the inflation it can’t be that easy for small businesses to stay afloat. As locals we have already been dealing with the high cost of living, we understand this... All we ask for supporting our local businesses is to be treated with respect. We also understand the cost of food in restaurants had increased and don't mind paying this but good grief $70 for both pizza! we expect at least a decent meal.