Mahony's Po-boys

It was recommended to us to visit Mahoney's Po-Boy Shop. After a lengthy garden tour walk-about adventure we headed in that direction. Once we arrived it didn't take long to be greeted and seated. The interior is low key and modestly decorated with a retro-esque flair. The staff were cool and kind. Each of us ordered a Po-boy of different varieties and some cold beverages. The full bar was a plus! Mahoney's was worth the visit. If you're in the area stop by and enjoy a tasty lunch served with a smile.

We had the crispy chicken buffalo pimento with normal fries. The chicken was, as it says, super crispy, light, and tender. The buffalo pimento spread was delicious, and the bread was light and fluffy. A half was enough for me and my husband each - grab a whole if you're super hungry. Fries were perfect as well - light, crispy, salted with some spice. The servers were delightful, and the atmosphere was great - sitting out front, people watching and listening to the blues on the speakers. Highly recommend.

I ate here for the first time in 2022. I told everyone very truthfully that the peacemaker was the best po’boy I’d ever eaten in my life (and I’ve eaten many). Fast forward to 2024, and I was so excited to return. I ordered the same. First, it came out wrapped in paper and not on a plate, so the fresh bread and ingredients were crushed, not unlike Subway. Secondly, and mostly importantly, the shrimp were salad/popcorn shrimp - tiny and barely any fried batter. Third, the bacon was underdone. Fourth, we were told that for the summer, we had to pay ahead at the bar and serve our own drinks behind the drink service station. The price I paid was not worth what I received. I didn’t mind pouring my own drink so much, but the food was really disappointing. I hope Mahony’s goes back to what made it a great place.

Get the Catfish Atchafalaya! It's amazing and even the corn maque choux served with it was impressive. We also got a catfish po'boy and fried green tomatoes neither of which were especially good. Not bad though. But seriously, the Atchafalaya ...

Had the best time here. Went two days in a row and sat at the bar. Great vibes! Will and Jenny took such good care of us, and made us not want to leave! Loved the apps and po boys, we tried the turkey, Cubano, and the gobbler (a post thanksgiving special). The bread was crusty but also so soft and didn’t tear up the roof of my mouth. The debris and gravy were fantastic also. Will definitely be coming back here on our next visit. The people and the food are a winner!

Cannot say enough good things about this place! From the moment you walk in you know you're in for something special. Poboys are absolutely phenomenal - the bread is so soft it practically melts in your mouth (I hope they never change it). Every bite is a testament to care and attention. Mahony's take pride in every detail. Highly recommend!

New restaurant that hasn’t been open long and it’s seems they won’t be open for much longer. Got some food to go but the food burnt and looks like absolute trash on top of that. Hate to see this kind of service from a BRAND NEW restaurant from a reputable chain.

We stopped in after reading positive reviews. Arrived around 530 knowing they close at 7pm. We got a warm welcome as soon as we walked in. We were told to choose any open table on the front patio or inside, and to check out the happy hour menu. A server came by right away and told us about the local taps and offered to bring a couple of beer samples. We made our menu choices (a shared po-boy which was delicious and an order of Debris Fries topped with the most incredible braised beef, gravy and other toppings). Our entire experience was 5 star. I only wish we'd found it sooner as we would have been back again. We highly recommend Mahony's!! Thanks to each of your staff for making this a favorite New Orleans meal.

It was recommended to us to visit Mahoney's Po-Boy Shop. After a lengthy garden tour walk-about adventure we headed in that direction. Once we arrived it didn't take long to be greeted and seated. The interior is low key and modestly decorated with a retro-esque flair. The staff were cool and kind. Each of us ordered a Po-boy of different varieties and some cold beverages. The full bar was a plus! Mahoney's was worth the visit. If you're in the area stop by and enjoy a tasty lunch served with a smile.

We had the crispy chicken buffalo pimento with normal fries. The chicken was, as it says, super crispy, light, and tender. The buffalo pimento spread was delicious, and the bread was light and fluffy. A half was enough for me and my husband each - grab a whole if you're super hungry. Fries were perfect as well - light, crispy, salted with some spice. The servers were delightful, and the atmosphere was great - sitting out front, people watching and listening to the blues on the speakers. Highly recommend.

I ate here for the first time in 2022. I told everyone very truthfully that the peacemaker was the best po’boy I’d ever eaten in my life (and I’ve eaten many). Fast forward to 2024, and I was so excited to return. I ordered the same. First, it came out wrapped in paper and not on a plate, so the fresh bread and ingredients were crushed, not unlike Subway. Secondly, and mostly importantly, the shrimp were salad/popcorn shrimp - tiny and barely any fried batter. Third, the bacon was underdone. Fourth, we were told that for the summer, we had to pay ahead at the bar and serve our own drinks behind the drink service station. The price I paid was not worth what I received. I didn’t mind pouring my own drink so much, but the food was really disappointing. I hope Mahony’s goes back to what made it a great place.

Get the Catfish Atchafalaya! It's amazing and even the corn maque choux served with it was impressive. We also got a catfish po'boy and fried green tomatoes neither of which were especially good. Not bad though. But seriously, the Atchafalaya ...

Had the best time here. Went two days in a row and sat at the bar. Great vibes! Will and Jenny took such good care of us, and made us not want to leave! Loved the apps and po boys, we tried the turkey, Cubano, and the gobbler (a post thanksgiving special). The bread was crusty but also so soft and didn’t tear up the roof of my mouth. The debris and gravy were fantastic also. Will definitely be coming back here on our next visit. The people and the food are a winner!

Cannot say enough good things about this place! From the moment you walk in you know you're in for something special. Poboys are absolutely phenomenal - the bread is so soft it practically melts in your mouth (I hope they never change it). Every bite is a testament to care and attention. Mahony's take pride in every detail. Highly recommend!

New restaurant that hasn’t been open long and it’s seems they won’t be open for much longer. Got some food to go but the food burnt and looks like absolute trash on top of that. Hate to see this kind of service from a BRAND NEW restaurant from a reputable chain.

We stopped in after reading positive reviews. Arrived around 530 knowing they close at 7pm. We got a warm welcome as soon as we walked in. We were told to choose any open table on the front patio or inside, and to check out the happy hour menu. A server came by right away and told us about the local taps and offered to bring a couple of beer samples. We made our menu choices (a shared po-boy which was delicious and an order of Debris Fries topped with the most incredible braised beef, gravy and other toppings). Our entire experience was 5 star. I only wish we'd found it sooner as we would have been back again. We highly recommend Mahony's!! Thanks to each of your staff for making this a favorite New Orleans meal.