Nyan P.
Yelp
Delicious food, I am told it is the second oldest restaurant left in Atlantic City by the waiter. I am gonna start off with the meal this time and if you want to read the rest feel free. Started off with some wine and the harvest moon, continuing my night with amaretto sours so felt it was on a similar course. Blood orange was super noticeable, hint of lime, with Campo Blanco which I believe is a tequila that is cooked with agave and orange.
No apps as we decided on trying their Knife and Fork in dinner special, which was almost a full course with corn and crab chowder, jersey tomato & buffalo mozzarella salad, and mains were lobster thermidor and filet mignon. Thermidor is when they cook the meat in like a rich wine sauce and then stuff it back in the shell with other ingredients, which this dish in particular happens to be sauce with mushrooms. Now although that would have been filling, it was time to enjoy a little extra tasting, added an order of the Cowboy Bone in 18 oz steak, sides of goat cheese au gratin potatoes, grilled asparagus and lobster risotto.
Lets start off with the bread, offered choice of multigrain and a cranberry walnut, with a small side of a rose decorated butter. The jersey tomato mozzarella salad was an elegantly put together dish, with a balsamic and basil dressing, not a full salad if your looking for something more filling. Chowder certainly had some lump crab meat mixed in the appearance was disappointing but the chowder was good, I would say that I wanted to taste more of the chowder but with every bite I was interrupted with several corn pieces, meaning there was a ton of corn in my chowder..
Entrees and sides came out altogether, the look of each dish was very appetizing, steaks were ordered medium rare, as they should. Starting off with the steaks the bone in cowboy was a hefty fella, seared well and juicy on the inside, cooked medium rare and pink just right. Steak was topped on a few pieces of broccoli rabe with a side of bearnaise sauce. Steak temperature was perfect and I enjoyed every piece with the creamy rich bearnaise. Filet did not have the first best appearance but was also cooked medium rare as instructed and quite juicy biting in. This was paired with the Au Poivre, if you are curious is a creamy sauce that is little more peppery that has been made with cognac. The look of the lobster thermidor was exciting with its red and orangey tones on the shell.
Sides that were picked were all super creamy so be prepared, lobster risotto quite rich creamy buttery sauce with chunks of lobster, the goat cheese au gratin potatoes were one of my favorites, lightly browned on top and creamy in each layer. Brussel sprouts were great, I enjoyed the dip and pieces were soft and tender, would have preferred a bit more char on the leaves but still enjoyable. Lastly shared a Vanilla Bean Crème Brulé, dessert was sweet and creamy vanilla flavor with hints of caramelized sugar, the topping was quite lightly caramelized as well and both blue and raspberries seemed pretty fresh.
Parking lot was unexpectedly small and outside appearance is like a but like a a colonial style carriage house. It was a Tuesday night, they had decorations that were Christmas ready, I did enjoy the soft warm lights around the windows. Walking in through the 2 doors, it had a warm inviting feeling with the bar right as you walk in, Table for 2 with reservation, seated right away, seamed like a please for conversation, seats two accommodate at least 7 in the larger tables and small settings for date night. Prices in my opinion are fair for a steakhouse, mid level prices, worth it for the food.
Waiter was warm and inviting, gave us a history of the inn, table settings were clean, seated by the window. Decorations of old photos from around Atlantic city. I would have totally loved to give 5 stars truly, as the food was amazing, waiters were very attentive at the beginning up until the entrees arrived. Waiter did spill some chowder on the table and almost my date, but not that important, as mistakes happen. After entrees were out, there was no more checking in if we needed anything until close to the end of the entrees, my plates with leftover butter, bread and utensils that we pushed towards the end of the table were also left until quite the end. One refill on the water and my date had been chewing ice for quite awhile. Hoping this was a one off and would love to experience the food again but it was a Tuesday.
Defiantly check it out, you won't regret the food, unless you go a bit deep with the creamy dishes and you are lactose. Enjoy and please let us know your experience!