Peter D.
Yelp
I've taken three different recreational cooking classes at ICE in the past few months, and I've got mixed feelings about the Institute overall.
Before I tackle the classes themselves, let me just say that the new facility is gorgeous. It's not exactly easy to find within the immense complex that is Brookfield Place, but once you do, it's clean and bright and well-designed. I may be a food nerd, but I actually got a little excited each time I walked around inside.
I can't speak to the actual career program here (other than it looks very professional, and people appear to be learning everywhere you look), but when it comes to the recreational classes, it seems that your experience is almost entirely dependent on what class you take, and who your instructors are.
I've had three instructors thus far, and I genuinely liked two of them. Those two were fun and knowledgable people, and both extremely funny (intentionally or otherwise*). The third was clearly very experienced, but (1) absolutely humorless and (2) disagreed with Jacques Pepin on certain fundamentals. I can't really abide either of those things on someone I'm going to spend a few hours with, cooking.
Anyway, here are the classes I took, and a few thoughts on each.
1. Knife Skills 1. Quite honestly, I only took this class because they called it a recommended prerequisite for Knife Skills 2, which I was genuinely interested in. Just so you are aware (I wasn't), this is an extremely basic course. If you've done any cooking at all, you won't learn too much unless you ask a LOT of questions and piss everyone off. This will just be general practice for chopping onions, peppers, carrots and more. Definitely skills any home cook should have, but if you already know how to do this, you can skip it. If the description of the class was more detailed, I would have.
2. Knife Skills 2: Butchery. The description of the class reads in part: "You will learn to properly debone a raw chicken and fillet a flounder. You will see how to carve a roast chicken to perfection---and more." Sounds good. A three hour course, I expected to get a lot out of this one.
Unfortunately, we neither learned how to carve a roast chicken, nor how to debone a raw chicken. We did learn how to break down a chicken, but I already knew how to break down a chicken. On the bright side, I did get a lot out of the experience of filleting a fish, and I did pick up some useful pointers, but I'm not sure what happened to the rest of the class (and the 'more').
Further, we spent the first two hours of the class on butchery, and the last hour "cooking" the chickens and fish we fabricated. What I signed up for was instruction on butchery; if I wanted to learn how to grill a chicken breast, I would've picked a different class. I can appreciate the fact that ICE may have wanted to offer more value, but send us home with the raw fish/chicken, and teach me for the whole class please, as opposed to 2/3 of it.
3. I signed my wife and I up for the Italian Cooking Party. Sometime after I paid and before the class happened, it turned into the Italian Cocktail Party. I thought it was my mistake at first, but the handouts for the class still read "Italian Cooking Party" and a couple of the other attendees told me that they were also expecting a cooking class. It seems as though we should've been informed of the change. Don't get me wrong, I love cocktails, and I had fun learning about the history and technique behind a few classics (although two of the three were Prosecco based, and extremely simple). But again, I didn't sign up to learn how to make cocktails.
Happily, I thoroughly enjoyed the food provided as well, and please believe I ate my fill.
However, I want to know how to make that beautiful porchetta. The new pizza ovens they have are amazing, and I'm glad the chefs allowed us to check it out and throw a pie in ourselves, but I would've much preferred to be learning how to make the dough and topping them ourselves, rather than mostly sitting around with strangers, waiting for our turn to make cocktails. It was a fun party, but with two of us, a pricey night out for something I wasn't trying to do in the first place.
As I'm writing this out, I'm realizing that my main issues with ICE are actually administrative. The website is awful, but my real problem is that the descriptions (in each of the three classes I took) were either incorrect, imprecise, or both. The classes themselves were great for who they are geared toward...but they are not cheap, and I must say that when I drop cash and I get something different than what I paid for, there is a lot of room for disappointment.
____________
*At one point my Knife Skills 2 instructor was showing me something on a chicken and she said, "Peter, I have a little bone. Touch it." This had me and a couple of my classmates giggling uncontrollably for the duration of the class because we are 12 years old, emotionally.