Ices Plain & Fancy

Such a cute & fun experience. Such friendly staff, cute, clean store. Omg the cinnamon! Highly recommend, but it is on the stronger cinnamon side! I loved it! Cherry cordial, & chocolate peanut my goodness so good & the peanuts are high quality. Can't wait to go back & try each flavor. It was a great birthday treat.

The last time I was here probably 8-9 years ago. Perhaps, I forgot about this place since it’s kinda out of my way. We stopped by for some sweet treat Friday when we were in the area. I still think it’s pretty cool to see they are making icecream in front of you using liquid nitrogen. I was also surprised that they had a very good Non Dairy menu. I was so tempting to get the boozy nitro ice cream but then I decided to save it for another day. I ended up getting German chocolate (non dairy) and Salted Dulce de leche. I liked the Salted Dulce de leche more, it was very creamy and tasted delicious but at the same time kinda sweet for my liking. I want to try their soy vanilla next time - it sounds interesting. Service was friendly and fast.

This place is one of a kind and AMAZING!!! The staff was great! The ice cream delicious. The atmosphere welcoming. The 'show' was super cool to watch! Definitely a must visit on your trip to town. Each order is made to order. Flash freeze and then serve. Have 21+ an older ice cream. Waffle cones are delicious. Nice size servings. Street parking. Outdoor eating area. 😋

Pretty cool and unique process to make ice cream. It is about the best flavored ice cream I have ever had. They have some ice cream with alcohol in it, but that is not what we got. We got normal ice cream. It is a bit on the pricey side but the flavor is worth it.

My husband and I come here all the time. It’s a 30 minute drive for us but it’s completely worth it. I had their seasonal gingerbread ice cream recently. It comes with a gingerbread cookie that’s made in house. Best gingerbread cookie I’ve ever had in my entire life.

First off I noticed behind the privacy glass, EVERYTHING was pristine, super clean, no stains, smears, nothing. I am very detail oriented and I've never seen a restaurant this spotless. I'm also violently allergic to dairy, and soy/wheat. The options they had for me were so exciting. It was the best ice cream I've had in my life

Ices Plain & Fancy's nitro ice creams are an exciting spectacle and offer a supremely smooth texture you can't really find anywhere else! I visit their establishment frequently and enjoy their creations, but I have found that they do lack consistency from time to time. Most recently I ordered the Dragonfly and the Peanut Butter Chocolate. The Dragonfly was both aesthetically pleasing and incredibly tasty, but the ratio for the Peanut Butter Chocolate was really off, with way too much peanut butter. Overall, I will keep returning, hoping that their consistency improves over time!

This was such a great hidden gem! They make the ice cream literally in front of you using nitrogen! It’s fascinating their process and they seem to have it down as an art! A very efficient staff. I got a boozy nitro ice cream based on an “old fashioned.” IT WAS INCREDIBLE!! Tasted just like an old fashioned but ice cream. Still came with a cherry and orange peel as well. If you are hesitant then don’t be. Just go for it because this place is worth it and worth the money!