First Slice Pie Cafe

Pie shop · Andersonville

First Slice Pie Cafe

Pie shop · Andersonville

9

5357 N Ashland Ave STE 1R, Chicago, IL 60640

Photos

First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by
First Slice Pie Cafe by Susie Lacocque
First Slice Pie Cafe by Jack Li
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null
First Slice Pie Cafe by null

Highlights

At First Slice Pie Cafe, a charming little spot in Andersonville, you can indulge in heavenly fruit and cream pies while supporting a great cause with every bite.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater

5357 N Ashland Ave STE 1R, Chicago, IL 60640 Get directions

firstslice.org
@firstslice

$$$$$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

5357 N Ashland Ave STE 1R, Chicago, IL 60640 Get directions

+1 773 275 4297
firstslice.org
@firstslice
𝕏
@firstslice

$$$$$$ · Menu

Features

dine in
takeout
delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay
wifi
outdoor seating

Last updated

Jul 6, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Though the chocolate peanut butter has many local fans, Food & Wine hailed First Slice’s apple pie as one of the best in the country. The cafe also has a charity component, so eating all that pie supports a good cause. There are locations in Andersonville and Ravenswood Manor." - Naomi Waxman, Ashok Selvam

Where to Find Sweet Pies in Chicago
View Postcard for First Slice Pie Cafe
@onthegrid

"The unassuming cafe serves more than sweets. First Slice functions as a social enterprise, fueling profits from the business toward providing meals and skill training to Chicagoans facing housing instability." - Rusty Design Co.

On the Grid : First Slice Pie Café
View Postcard for First Slice Pie Cafe
@infatuation

"This is a welcoming little cafe serving all kinds of soups, salads, and sandwiches. And pie, of course, because with a name like First Slice Pie Cafe, there’d better be pie. It’s really the pie that you should be getting here (if that wasn’t obvious)—either the peanut butter or something more classic like the apple. Eat it there, or get it to-go. Or do both, and have more pie." - sam faye, adrian kane, john ringor

Where To Eat In Andersonville
View Postcard for First Slice Pie Cafe
@infatuation

"First Slice in Andersonville has some of our favorite sweet pies like chocolate peanut butter and pumpkin, and some great vegan ones, too. But they also have a few savory options like  chicken or turkey pot pies if you don’t want to deal with carving a bird this year. You can see their whole selection and place an order here." - john ringor

Where To Preorder Thanksgiving Pies In Chicago
View Postcard for First Slice Pie Cafe
@infatuation

"This is a welcoming little Andersonville cafe serving all kinds of soups, salads, and sandwiches. And pie, of course, because with a name like First Slice Pie Cafe, there’d better be pie. That's what you should be getting here (if that wasn’t obvious)—either the peanut butter or something more classic like the apple. Eat it there, or get it to-go. Or do both, and have more pie. photo credit: Jack Li" - Adrian Kane

First Slice Pie Cafe - Review - Andersonville - Chicago - The Infatuation
View Postcard for First Slice Pie Cafe