Fini Pizza Amagansett

"Fini’s original location is in Williamsburg, but look for their green and white stripe facade near a spacious lawn on Main Street in Amagansett. The retro-style pizzeria offers slices and whole pies, with a white pizza topped with the ideal trinity of soft fontina, sharp parm, and melty mozzarella, with a lemon wedge on the side. Classic cheese and pepperoni are excellent too, as are the Sicilian slices. We also love the caesar—the crispy romaine gets coated in a not-too-thick, lemony dressing and decked out with garlicky breadcrumbs and enough grated parm to make the $15 pricetag worth it." - melissa kravitz hoeffner, team infatuation

"Fini’s original location is in Williamsburg, but look for their green and white stripe facade near a spacious lawn on Main Street in Amagansett. The retro-style pizzeria offers slices and whole pies, with a white pizza topped with the ideal trinity of soft fontina, sharp parm, and melty mozzarella, with a lemon wedge on the side. Classic cheese and pepperoni are excellent too, as are the Sicilian slices. We also love the caesar—the crispy romaine gets coated in a not-too-thick, lemony dressing and decked out with garlicky breadcrumbs and enough grated parm to make the $15 pricetag feel worthwhile." - Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner

"After opening up in Williamsburg, a second Fini Pizza is coming to Amagasset sometime this summer in the old Astro’s Pizza space. Fini comes from a Lilia owner, which is a fun fact you can share with your neighbor while you’re waiting in line for a white pie slice. If it’s anything like its Brooklyn predecessor, you can count on classic but fancy $5 slices, pillowy Sicilian pies, and generously dressed caesar salads. " - Anne Cruz

"The co-owner of one of Williamsburg's most hard to get into restaurants, Lilia, opened a break-off pizzeria called Fini in 2022. This summer Sean Feeney set to debut a not-yet-open sibling location for Fini Pizza in Amagansett." - Beth Landman

You have to order ahead at like 2pm to get pizza for the night but worth it! Shallot pizza, caesar salad and lemon sorbet always.