Fancy

Jewelry designer · Denny Blaine

Fancy

Jewelry designer · Denny Blaine

4

2921 E Madison St Suite 2, Seattle, WA 98112

Photos

Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null
Fancy by null

Highlights

Nestled near Pike Place Market, Fancy is a vibrant, artist-owned jewelry boutique where you can design unique pieces, enjoy sustainable practices, and support local talent.  

Placeholder
Placeholder

2921 E Madison St Suite 2, Seattle, WA 98112 Get directions

heyfancy.com
@hiya_fancy

$$

Information

Static Map

2921 E Madison St Suite 2, Seattle, WA 98112 Get directions

+1 206 424 2921
heyfancy.com
@hiya_fancy

$$

Features

delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Feb 19, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@onthegrid

"Tucked away just a few blocks from Westlake Center is one of the coziest and friendliest retail stores downtown. If you appreciate handmade, artisan products, Fancy is a spot you have to visit. The storefront exudes plenty good vibes that complement thoughtfully curated pieces of art, design, and jewelry by independent artists—all without coming across as bourgie or pretentious. Though Fancy focuses on jewelry, the shop has some amazing, colorful buys, and aesthetics that are sure to inspire." - Parker

On the Grid : Fancy
test
@afar

"Fancy Jewels, Ethically Made Just down the block from Schmancy (get it?), Fancy is a charming little jewelry boutique with gorgeous, modern jewelry and art. They’re a Seattle -based company focused on producing high-quality jewelry that is 100% handmade of ethically sourced materials: all precious metals are recycled, and all gemstones and diamonds are either repurposed or Kimberly Process approved. Prices start below $100 and go up quickly, so if you can’t afford a broken heart, don’t go in and fall in love with their high-end and beautifully made designer pieces."

The Best Shopping in Seattle
test
@afar

"Fancy Jewels, Ethically Made Just down the block from Schmancy (get it?), Fancy is a charming little jewelry boutique with gorgeous, modern jewelry and art. They’re a Seattle -based company focused on producing high-quality jewelry that is 100% handmade of ethically sourced materials: all precious metals are recycled, and all gemstones and diamonds are either repurposed or Kimberly Process approved. Prices start below $100 and go up quickly, so if you can’t afford a broken heart, don’t go in and fall in love with their high-end and beautifully made designer pieces."

Seattle: Best of Belltown
test
@onthegrid

"Fancy, Downtown by Parker. Tucked away just a few blocks from Westlake Center is one of the coziest and friendliest retail stores downtown. If you appreciate handmade, artisan products, Fancy is a spot you have to visit. The storefront exudes plenty good vibes that complement thoughtfully curated pieces of art, design, and jewelry by independent artists—all without coming across as bourgie or pretentious. Though Fancy focuses on jewelry, the shop has some amazing, colorful buys, and aesthetics that are sure to inspire."

Seattle
test

Kyle Shepard

Google
Such a great store! The owner was very helpful and she does amazing custom jewelry. It's pretty small but they seem to have a lot to choose from. I appreciate that some of the jewelry and gifts are nicely priced as well.

Lioness X

Google
Great unique pieces. Fun vibe, quality items, and community events sometimes. (Trunk shows/pop ups) Design your own rings and pieces - solo. Mother daughter. Partners. You can use their materials or and also bring in your own pieces to be melted down and recreated… Sustainable … Recycle - key values that Fancy encourages and makes it easier to do. Bring in your metals/ jewelry to co-create new pieces or donate old broken pieces Intentional shopping - support local women owned business; sometimes they have great specials connected to the Intentionalist programs with significant savings and incentives. Loved the wooden sunglasses from Italy $80 but with the special meant I got them for $55 Thank you Tuesday - You helped make the shopping a feel good fun informative experience.

Chloe Lee-Tjenos

Google
Sally is incredibly talented, kind, and thoughtful in her designs. For those who value quality, timeless design, and uniqueness, Fancy is an oasis of inspiration. I can't recommend Sally and her business enough, I have had the honor of working with her on cutsom designs, repairs, resizing, and altering various pieces over the years and I consider her workmanship to be of the highest quality. Sally is the best around!

Evan Clifthorne

Google
This handmade jewelry boutique will be one of the best you've ever been to. This is an artist-owned shop, and her work is expressive, playful, and built to last. My partner and I had our rings custom made here, and the experience couldn't have been better. You'll often find the artist herself working at her in-store studio, behind the counter, with metals and tools and an overflowing abundance of creative energy just spilling into air. The jewelry ranges from affordable to one-of-a-kind, and often includes work from other local artists in Seattle. This store is at the edge of Belltown, just steps from Pike Place Market, and it's worth a go, whether you're a tourist, a longtime local, or anywhere between! Enjoy! :)

Cari Stalter

Google
I don't wear anything that isn't from Fancy anymore. I've had custom pieces made, including a super cool medical alert bracelet. I also love the jewelry and art from local artists for sale. Great place to get a gift for a friend or spoil yourself.

Blair Carleton

Google
So much fun to go in with my daughter and have each of us design our very own custom ring!

Justine May

Google
My husband and I got our wedding bands here, and he got my engagement ring here. High quality, beautiful pieces of not just jewelry, but art. I literally want everything in the store... even the plants.

John McLaughlin

Google
Went here 5 years ago to get our wedding rings. Went there again today to get a replacement. Still super lovely and helpful. Highly recommended.

Hanna S.

Yelp
Great unique pieces. Fun vibe, quality items, and community events sometimes. (Trunk shows/pop ups) Gift ideas to lovely jewelry. Various price points too Co create rings for you and your partner / yourself/ mother daughter....as just some examples. Sustainable ... Recycle are key values that Fancy encourages and makes it easy to do. Bring in your metals/ jewelry to make new pieces or donate. Workshop is on site. Support local artists- start from scratch or and bring in your own stones/ metals. You can even bring in one metal that you do not wear anymore and use that for credit for another Intentional shopping - support local women owned business; Fancy through the Internationalist program offer valuable specials with significant savings and incentives. Loved the wooden sunglasses from Italy $80 but the special meant I got them for $55 Thank you Tuesday - You helped make the shopping experience a feel good fun informative event.

Beckett S.

Yelp
Love the new location in Madison Valley! Fancy is filled with a joyful collection of fine and funky jewelry. Made in house by artist-owner Sally Brock, but she's stocked her store with jewelry & blown glass votive holders, vases, bowls, pottery and more from other gifted local craftspeople.

Becky B.

Yelp
Fancy is the best, her store is cute and has a nice variety of ready-made--by-local jewelers at different price points so it's great for gifts. They sell cards there too so it's easy when I am last-minute shopping but want to look like I planned ahead. I love everything Sally has made for me. I have a wedding set from here, a few necklaces and Sally even made earrings that I can wear - I have sensitive ears so Sally made me the lightest wire earrings you can imagine.

Joan S.

Yelp
I had a terrible experience Do not shop in her store She is extremely unprofessional Does not have any idea what she is doing Says that she sized my bracelets She did not she lied I would not even give her a one star Run as fast as you can Very poor work Not reliable at all But she did give me my money back I will probably report her to the BBB

Ashley M.

Yelp
I'm so lucky my partner let me pick out my engagement ring and even luckier that I found Sally! It is so incredibly beautiful. I was able to pick a rough stone, have it custom cut, and have Sally create a beautiful ring. It's exactly what I imagined and is just stunning. I can't wait to pick my wedding ring. There are so many different options at all different prices and Sally was great about working with us. I was really happy to find a local artist who works closely with other local artists (like the stone cutter) and uses recycled materials and has great sustainability policies. Truly beautiful things in the store and tons of cool lights and artwork too.

Bitsy G.

Yelp
Sally at Fancy helped my fiance and I create the perfect engagement ring, on top of turning my old wedding ring into an amazing pendant. In the shape of my dear departed cat, no less (as close to spitting image as possible in jewelry form; it's absolutely adorable)! She also had solutions for what to do with an old engagement ring my fiance had been holding onto for years. The entire experience was very enjoyable and relaxed. Also, fancy's website is fantastic, and everything is photographed beautifully. There were several rings I wanted to see in person after looking online, and I was not disappointed. I did a little online shopping before going into Fancy; I did not see anything close to what fancy offers, even at "boutique" jewelry shops.

jessica n.

Yelp
I stopped in one day to chat with Sally about reworking my wedding band and engagement ring in a way that I could wear it every day working at me spa without worrying about it scratching clients and tough enough to withstand all the manual labor behind running your own business. She nailed it! In two weeks time I had the ring I had been dreaming of! The ring was relatively affordable, and I received credit for the gold in my original set. On top of having a beautiful ring I can't stop looking at, Sally creates a friendly inviting vibe in her store. Highly recommend!

Sara L.

Yelp
I picked up my beloved little adornment from Sally a couple of weeks ago and have worn it every day since. I love my ring so much I just can't even. After falling in love with watermelon bicolor tourmaline I started sourcing my own stones, not knowing just how difficult it would be to find a fine jeweler who was willing to work with provided jems. When I finally found the perfect stone, the jeweler I purchased it from didn't have any settings that suited me: this is a gift for myself, to help ease my acceptance of turning 40 this year with no kids, no husband, and no engagement ring in my foreseeable future. My life doesn't look like my friends'. And that's OK. But I want a ring. And that, I decided, I can do for myself. I wanted a right hand ring, that looks like a right hand ring, NOT an engagement ring. So I walked into Fancy and met Sally and showed her the stone and told her I wanted a right hand ring that did NOT look like an engagement ring (although I'm pretty sure I actually used expletives because by that point I'd seen so many f#$*ing engagement ring settings I thought this project was a lost cause) and she was stoked. Sally was amazing. She met me right where I was energetically ... she sketched ideas, showed me samples, gave great advice, finished my sentences and read my mind, and was really awesome to work with even though my budget was lower than what you'll see on the pricetags in her shop. We settled on a wide hammered silver band (as opposed to white gold, to keep the piece in my budget) and she built a bold, beautiful setting out of red gold that perfectly fits and shows off my stone. When I picked up the finished ring I almost cried; I wear it daily, and it's like it was made just for my finger (because it was, and Sally knows her you-know-what). Not only is the piece of jewelry itself a treasure; the whole experience exceeded my hopes for giving myself this gift and I'll treasure both the ring AND the experience and energy associated with it. Thank you so much, Sally! Hugs from Watermelon Sara!

Shauna B.

Yelp
I fell in love with Fancy Jewels before I met my man; and I decided right away that if I ever got married, I wanted Sally to make our rings. When I did meet the right fella years later, I talked him into visiting Fancy to design rings before we were even engaged. I really believe that our visit to Fancy was one of the first experiences that made him think seriously about getting hitched. When we went in and talked with Sally, it was the first time he ever realized that we could have a wedding (and a marriage) that reflects us; and the rings we designed were a big part of that. Sally made us an amazing pair of rings. She called them "wonder twin rings" because the dots in his line up with the sapphires in mine when we roll them together. Even though a re-sizing slightly threw off the way they line up; our delight in our wonder twin powers remains undiminished. Sally--you are fantastic. Thank you!

Nish N.

Yelp
If I were a girl, I'd shop here all the time. Super cute and oftentimes unique clothing, typically from local designers. Very girly, but still with enough sass for those nights where you need to woo or be wooed. The store is a little disorganized, but then again, that's sort of like sifting through your friend with the best clothes' walk-in closet. Cool artwork that's for sales covers the walls, and the owner even makes some of the custom jewelry (make sure to check out the class rings collection!). Special props to Fancy Pants for at one time carrying Yelp Boy Shorts and Tank Tops!

Ellen W.

Yelp
Fancy is the coziest, most beautiful place. Every piece of jewelry, whether it's 20 dollars or 500, is displayed in a thoughtful, loving way. And yes, their price range really is that broad! The folks that work there are warm and helpful without being pushy. They're also really funny. They're also really cool. I'm at a point in my life where my jewelry purchases are more ceramic cat beads than anything else, but if I ever wife someone you'd better believe that hypothetical life partner and I would buy our life rings at fancy. That they have me covered then and now is just one more reason to love this shop. Seriously, y'all should see my ceramic cat bead! There is not a better jewelry store.

Lee A.

Yelp
I was looking for a way to communicate a permanent domestic partnership with the Hapa Boy. Laugh if you will, but this is not an easy thing to communicate in a word littered with cushion cut flashies via Kim Kardashian-esque, overly made up little bridies. The solution was the Unwedding Ring made in strore by this amazing little downtown shop. The minute I saw it, I knew it was perfect. So is Fancy. Sally, the owner, is adorable, incredibly warm, and genuinely interested in helping you pick the perfect thing - even if you're not planning on spending thousands of dollars. In fact, it would be kind of hard to spend thousands, since everything at Fancy is so reasonably priced. I'm not a big jewelry person, but I admit it, I squee'd a couple of times at her collection of sweet temptations [and spent more than planned, but how many times do you engage in a permanent domestic partnership?;) Don't spend money at a big box cookie cutter meh-factory, when you could hang out at Fancy and find something uniquely beautiful. Seriously, don't do it. Embrace your inner awesome at Fancy.

Mike B.

Yelp
To be frank I was just coming in to see what the store was all about - Just curious . I am from out of town and my partner and I walked in . There was someone - I assume the owner behind a counter speaking to someone else - a customer I imagine . I was in the store for maybe 5-10 mins not a hello to either myself or my partner ...... not even a glance . I find that rude and classist . Whatever skills the store team has and clearly they do with the great reviews was certainly not shown or offered to me . Poor service !

Mary Lou T.

Yelp
I worked with Sally at Fancy to transform an old wedding set into a fabulous new companion to my wedding ring. I had a clear idea of what I wanted and Sally helped make it better still, working with Kalee at Sholdt to create it. I cannot say enough good things about my experience with Fancy. From my first few words with Sally I knew I had come to the right place. The store exudes good vibes and warmth. I picked up my ring today and I nearly cried, I was so happy with it. I will be back for my fiancé's band, which I'm sure will also be a fun and happy experience.

Julie F.

Yelp
Sally Brock makes beautiful jewelry all by herself. We asked her to help us design our not so traditional engagement ring, complete with secret messages spelled out with rubies and inscriptions on the inside. Not only did she not laugh at us, she embraced the idea and was full of even more suggestions. The engagement ring is absolutely gorgeous as are the matching platinum bands we just picked up for the wedding. Working with Sally was a dream! Even if you aren't getting married, be sure to stop by, because her shop is full of her awesome designs as well as great stuff from other local designers.

Nic D.

Yelp
Sally is an absolute joy to work with. She is smart, funny, creative, welcoming, warm, a terrific listener and the kind of gal you'd want to hang out with all the time. Three years ago, she made palladium wedding bands for my husband and me that were just to our spec - simple, brushed bands with our anniversary date inside. She also made me a small ring with a stone set up high that nestled beautifully with my band and some other small rings I wore on that finger. We had created the perfect stacked set. Or, so I thought.... Not too long ago, I received a ring that belonged to my late father. It was gold (and not a particularly pretty gold at that) with four small diamonds set in it. I took it to Sally and together we dreamed up the most incredible ring. She pulled out the diamonds and she sold the gold for "green" gold which is gold + silver*. That mix creates the most amazing hue! it's other worldly beautiful. It looks amazing with the white metal hues of my other rings. Sally set the small diamonds up off the band in perfect little bezels. We decided on the placement together so that they look sort of scattered and one is set just off the edge of the ring to fit neatly with the ring worn above or below it. She also made me a thin gold band to match. NOW, I have the perfect stacked set! The shop has changed up its interiors and displays over the years and the overall goal seems to be to create a wonderland. There is so much to look at and ogle. It's a place where jewelry dreams undoubtedly come true. It's colorful and sparkly and carries some amazing items from local crafts folks beside the jewelry. This shop is my sentimental favorite in all of Seattle and I look forward to working on more creations with Sally for years to come. * I hope I got that right. All I am certain of is that it is beautiful. Sally has taught us about metals we'd never heard of and that there is a wide range of options. Even that small detail made working with her more interesting and fun.

Dean C.

Yelp
I wanted to like this place - I walked in and it was very nicely decorated and seemed like a great place to get a unique vintage ring for my partner. I mentioned my budget ($2000) and that I was looking ideally for lab-created or second-hand stones (so as to avoid the ecological/social costs of newly mined) and it sounded like they had both. But as I started asking some questions about what they had in stock, they seemed to just want me to leave the store. While she showed me a few pieces that were either toys (like $200 moissianite) or way too expensive, they almost shamed me for not having looked at their instagram and website before walking in. They kept telling me to go check those to see everything else. What kind of sales pitch is that? Leave the store and look at what we have online? I had just come from another jeweler up in Ballard (Baraka), where the owner very kindly sat down with me and talked me through what he had both in the store and online, patiently showing me the inventory and trying to help me find something that worked for my budget and preferences. I'd understand this feverish desire to send me, a poor grad student looking for an engagement ring, out of the store if there were a dozen high-rollers looking for $10,000 rings lined up out the door. But there was no one else there. Why couldn't they just pull out their phone, or pull up their site on their computer to show me what they had? I had found them on Yelp when I was nearby and thought what the hell, let's see what they've got - I just saw good reviews and wandered in. Isn't that what businesses want? This is a classicly pretentious hipster place, where the staff will look at you condescendingly if you mention a style that isn't hip enough - like a princess cut. I wasn't wedded to such a design, it's just what I knew my partner liked. A patient salesperson who actually wanted my business might have talked me through other options and why, rather than just sending me packing. I'm giving this place three stars instead of one because I'm sure these guys make great unique rings, for the right kind of customers. Apparently I wasn't worth their time.

Helen W.

Yelp
I came into Fancy Pants the other day when the sky was gray and the sun was no where to be found. As soon as I stepped into this store, my spirits were lifted. The owners of Fancy and Pants have joined forces to make Fancy Pants. This is a cute and funky little shop with lots of hand made jewelries, purses, t-shirts, jammies, and unders. Their jewelries actually made me go 'oooh' out loud. Best of all, a lot of their jewelries can be customized with a name, picture or text of your choice. So next time the weather gets you down, go into Fancy Pants and pick up some garden gnome jammies and a ring that says 'you rock'.

Tim L.

Yelp
Sally made custom wedding rings for my wife and I. They came out beautifully. She used industrial-grade black diamonds to create braille insets of our wedding date. They really came out spectacular, on time and on budget. I can't say enough great things about the process.

Victoria G.

Yelp
Fancy is the spot to spoil yourself silly. Wonderful local jewelry designers, art and gifts. Not as spendy as the name suggests

Alison K.

Yelp
I have bought jewelry of all types at Fancy, and every time I wear them it makes me happy and I get compliments. The selection is fresh, the presentation is creative, and the owner is a delight (she's usually in there). It is a treat to go in whenever I'm nearby - fun to check out what art is on the walls (usually a local artist) and what new pieces are in the displays. Some of the pieces are the owner's work, and some are from other jewelers. The proprietor is clearly selective about what she'll carry, and I like 99% of it. I just wish I could spend more money there...

Maria C.

Yelp
The Trilogy of the Funky is complete with Pants. Fancy, Schmancy, Pants. heh. Having seen Fancy and Schmancy I just didn't feel complete without visiting Pants. I can now move on with my life. I didn't find any underwear that would look like it belonged on anyone over 30 - not saying how far over 30 - but tons of stuff for my teenage daughter. Cute tap pants, boy pants, briefs, bras, T-shirts. They even have men's undies for really brave and funky boys. I did fall for the knitted tote bag with the heart eyed skull on it, but again thought that carrying it down the street on my over 30 arm might creep people out. Cute with an edge describes this small store. It just doesn't describe me.

Kristen R.

Yelp
You can't leave this place empty handed. Beautiful jewelry, friendly service, cool undies. You'll find it all at Fancy + Pants

Kayla J.

Yelp
Sally is the brilliant!!! My fiancé and I came in here after a ridiculously long search for a unique engagement ring. I spent a few minutes looking around while Sally was speaking with another customer. After giving her an idea of what I was looking for she pulled out a few boxes of gems. She helped pick out stones for my ring and offered wonderful suggestions. After leaving Fancy, I felt very confident that my ring would turn out perfectly. From my meeting with Sally, I could tell that she genuinely loves her business and is very knowledgeable. My fiancé and I also really loved the idea of supporting a local business. My ring was finished quicker than I had expected and it went beyond my expectations.

Alison K.

Yelp
Sally rocks! I spent a lot of time trying to figure out what I even wanted in an engagement ring; I'd just said yes and hadn't really considered what sort of things go into getting married, I just wanted to BE married. I have concerns about diamonds, solitaires are boring no matter what sort of gem is used, and I've always preferred jewelry that's unique rather than merely sparkly. I finally ran across the Fancy website, and I loved everything! Even the Claude the Bear ring. Who doesn't love a ring with a bear on it, even if you might not wear it? My fiance and I were both pretty nervous when we stopped by; it's not like either of us have ever bought an engagement ring or commissioned custom jewelry. Sally is a great listener, super-knowledgeable about her craft and materials, and was really patient as we figured out what would reflect us best. I chose a diamond Robot ring with a black diamond (these are lab-grown and really cool looking, which definitely calms my nerves about conflict diamonds.) Sally talked with us until she was certain she understood what we wanted, and hung on to her notes in case we came back about some of our other ideas. (I bet we will!) We picked up the ring last week and it's awesome. The thick profile means I always remember I'm wearing it, which is a sweet reminder on an engagement ring. I'm really excited about gold rivets, which my fiance's dad thought were really cool too. Definitely stop by whether you're looking for something off-the-wall or a little more traditional, I'm confident Sally can get you what you need. I know I'll be back, I've been dreaming of her Adhoc ring design for a wedding band, and she said she can make it stack with my engagement ring.

Jessica R.

Yelp
Cute, eclectic shop with jewelry, bags, lingerie and accessories from indie designers. Friendly owner and a really fun selection.

Annah E.

Yelp
This little shop will become your next, new best friend. The jewelry is eclectic and gorgeous in its simplicity. Stylish, fun gifts and the owner is very hands-on. When I ordered white gold bands she met with me in person several times and was happy to e-mail and keep me posted about the metal, cost and finish date. I needed the ring re-sized (was too small) and it only took a few minutes while I waited. If you stick around and chat, you may even be offered a popsicle!

Louise W.

Yelp
After nearly 3 years of searching for the perfect jeweler to help me re-set a family heirloom, I finally found Sally at Fancy after reading reviews on Yelp. An initial hour-long consultation lead to a creative partnership that resulted in converting several rings -- including my husband's white-gold band, my yellow gold band, my cabochon sapphire engagement ring and my grandmother's European-cut 2.25 carat diamond -- into 2 of the most beautiful, unique and breathtaking rings I could have imagined. Sally made brilliant use of all the supplied metal and stones and added a few of her own, to create these dream rings. I carry her cards with me so that when I get the inevitable "Oh my God where did you get those rings?!" I can hand over the Fancy card and say, "Sally made these, aren't they fabulous?"

fran c.

Yelp
I work a block away from this place, and love stopping by. Why? The eye candy. If you like Kay Jeweler's get gone, because this is the place for those who want jewelry that actually represents some personality. Sally the owner is great, plus she is a genius at mother's day gift ideas (check out her custom made rings and necklaces) and her wedding bands are amazing. Very refreshing.

Emily P.

Yelp
Well, we did it. We bought an engagement ring. And Sally and Erich (the co-owners) of Fancy couldn't have been any more patient, thoughtful and excited. Sally's rings are all individually created, and so the process allowed us to design exactly what we envisioned. In fact, Sally shared, "I would have been disappointed if you had just picked one off the shelf." She made it for us in record time, kept us up to date on the status, and in short, it's resulted in the perfect ring. And the rest of the stuff in the store is quite cool and different too- well worth a pop in if you're strolling around Belltown or near the market.

Lara H.

Yelp
Sally and Fancy are incredible. My fiancée and I knew we wanted unique engagement rings that would fit our budget, and we were feeling discouraged after going to several other shops who either laughed at us or showed us their plainest, ugliest bands that were still over our budget. We walked in to Fancy with low expectations, but walked out with a sketch of our custom coordinated constellation rings with a hammered finish and both of our birthstones, with a quote well within our budget. They even worked with us to have the rings done at different times for our surprise proposals! Compared to a previous chain diamond jeweler experience, the customer service and quality was a night and day improvement! I would recommend them to anyone looking to buy unique jewelry and actually have fun in the process!

Matthew R.

Yelp
I don't get it? How can anyone list this store for engagement rings? I went shopping there recently and they only have a few dozen and none of them were very impressive. The store is a little hole in the wall. They might be good for some lower priced local artists work, but this is definitely not a store you'd want to go for engagement rings. Sorry for the low rating, but people should know what this store is all about before wasting their time shopping there only to find a few dozen dinky engagement and wedding rings.

Tyler M.

Yelp
We had the best experience working with Sally at Fancy. She custom-made our wedding rings and was extremely personable, a good listener, and very patient when we were having trouble deciding what we wanted. We didn't come in with a vision and Sally showed us the entire universe of options and we ended up with rings that suit us perfectly. We are beyond satisfied and it seemed like Sally took great joy in designing and making the rings. One thing we especially appreciated was when we went in for the initial band fitting, the ring hadn't turned out exactly how I wanted and Sally basically started over from scratch to rebuild the ring. She really cares about what you want and your happiness. Thank you, Sally.

Liberty H.

Yelp
Sally designed our wedding rings for us. They are beautiful and no one has anything like them. Sally is rad.

Candice S.

Yelp
Sally rocks! She made me and my brand new Fiancee a set of beautiful rings, using stones and metal from a vintage family ring. We love our rings so much, and Sally made the whole process easy and stress free. Highly recommended!

Gabe N.

Yelp
I was pretty clueless when I started looking for an engagement ring but Sally was really helpful. She sent me a bunch of options in line with my budget and ideas for styles, and was patient with me when I changed my mind multiple times (thanks Sally). Also she was able to rush my order to make sure I had the ring ready for a trip. The end product was beautiful. Very satisfied customer.

Susan M.

Yelp
I stumbled across this fabulous boutique recently and discovered Kimber Elements here! I picked up a pair of fantastic Paragon Earrings and am wearing them as we speak! I am a HUGE fan of structural jewelry! I loved this place! It's so pretty and tasteful in here and the owner, Sally is really cool, friendly and has great taste. Now, I can't stop thinking about the matching Paragon necklace they have at Fancy! Talk about an obsession!

nc g.

Yelp
Sally made our wedding rings a few weeks ago and we could not be happier. My partner had his heart set on a specific kind of texture and was not finding one that he liked anywhere. On a whim we visited the store and fell in love with everything there. Sally was helpful but not pushy, very easy-going, and when we picked up the rings gave us our choice of the cutest ring boxes ever. We want to wear the rings now though the wedding is 5 months away-- they are so pretty and fit us and our personalities perfectly. We are completely satisfied with Fancy Jewelry and would recommend them highly to any couple looking for wedding rings.

Irene B.

Yelp
We couldn't me more pleased with our wedding bands. We wanted bands that were simple, yet elegant, and Fancy delivered. The rings are perfectly us. Sally, the wonderful designer and shop owner, really made the whole experience enjoyable, comfortable, and exciting! We recommend!

Jen H.

Yelp
I just picked up my wedding ring and am so very in love with it! Sally is beyond fantastic to work with and her jewelery is amazing. I've lost count now as to how many times I changed my mind about things or came in or called to ask questions about my ring and she always made time for me and was so patient and helpful with no pressure or rush for me to decide (in fact, if anything, she kept offering more and more options and ideas to make it even more of what I wanted). She helped me come up with a way to make my ring really simple, which I wanted, and yet one of a kind. Finally I decided on something I just love. I'm not the kind of person who gets giddy about things but seriously, besides getting to marry my favorite person in the world I am soooooo excited to get to wear that ring! Thank you, Sally!

kirsten h.

Yelp
Sally made wedding rings for my husband and I, and not a day goes by that I don't look at mine and love it. (Same is true for him...). We went to her with an idea, and with some crazy pictures, and she turned our idea into beautiful rings. She worked with us every step of the way, to make sure that the rings would be perfect. And they are.

Laurie C.

Yelp
If you're looking for something utterly unique to make your sweetheart feel exactly as special as he or she is, this is the place you will certainly find it! I was looking for the perfect graduation gift for my girlfriend and dropped by to chat with Sally about it. She helped me decide on a design and was able to produce it on my short timeline. The finished product was absolutely gorgeous. My girlfriend cried when I gave it to her! If you don't want to go custom, the shop is full of lovely things that you won't find anywhere else. Sally rocks and I can't recommend Fancy enough!

Page U.

Yelp
Sally is a true artist and craftswoman. She spent several hours with us, helping us to figure out what we wanted our rings to look like, and guiding us while not being in the least bit controlling. I couldn't be more pleased with the gorgeous rings or the experience of working with her. Highly, highly recommended.

Levi B.

Yelp
Sally is a great designer/manufacturer. She made a one-of-a-kind ring for my father's 70th birthday. He loved it, and he is a pain in the neck to please. The ring was well designed, well executed, and the price was right.
Wood grain pattern