Brian S.
Yelp
Seeing Backyard go was very sad, but Crozet Pizza did a good job of sprucing the place up while keeping it relatively true to its roots. The place is more of a "chill" bar than its Corner peers, and has a really nice vibe.
We finally got to try it out for an extended evening of dinner/drinking. (I had tried to come in the past, but eventually left after an hour of waiting when we found out that the host, who had continually assured us we would be seated soon, had lost the list of waiting guests).
The menu is strange. There's pizzas and a couple salads, and that's that. (No appetizers, sides, etc.) I wouldn't put much weight into the pre-selected pies, which are pretty unexciting. There's a giant toppings list, so just make your own,
The pizza itself is very good. Nothing special, but the toppings are fresh, the crust is good, and it's cooked in a more "authentic" way than Mellow. The prices are great, especially when I compare it to DC. ~15 dollar pitchers of rotating decent beers, 5 dollar cocktails, and 15 dollar pizzas with toppings.
The service was laughably terrible. Paper plates? Strange, but whatever. Long waits? It's a college town, sure.
But come on. Crozet Pizza only serves pizza, but doesn't own those little pizza stackers that lift them off the table. The waitress basically moved our plates to the corner of the table and stuck 2 pizzas down instead, which was hilarious. We found another table to bring over to put the pies on. We ordered drinks, which sat at the bar for LITERALLY 10 minutes until I decided to go get them myself. This happened twice. She'd disappear for huge periods of time, then come back and ask us if we wanted the check ("NO! We want to order more things again!") Maybe our graduation made us snobby...but that was all brutal.
If you're going to hang out, eat pizza, and drink in a relaxed atmosphere...and see past the service issues, Crozet Pizza's great.