"The flavors at Caffè Panna in Gramercy (and at their Greenpoint location) change daily, so come here when you want to be surprised and excited by way of dairy. There are almost no simple options here: you'll walk away holding something like vanilla with peanut butter and salty snickers, fior di panna with sicilian olive oil and sea salt. And if you're looking for hard ice cream (or an affogato), they've got that too." - hannah albertine, willa moore, arden shore, molly fitzpatrick