"Coffee: $3.00 This quintessential Upper West Diner was revamped in 2021, by the same group behind 24-hour spot Coppelia. (They're currently working on reopening Williamsburg’s Kellogg’s Diner). Other than some sourdough and Lavazza on its menu, Old John's still looks and feels like a regular diner, but one that's functioning at peak efficiency. This is ideal when you need a thick burger and a martini before a show at nearby Lincoln Center. Save space for their challah french toast, and homemade ice cream." - willa moore, molly fitzpatrick, will hartman, bryan kim, neha talreja, sonal shah