Sarabeth's Central Park South

A Classic Brunch Spot Like most brunch places in New York City, this spot gets very busy on weekends. Without a reservation, be prepared for crowds and a long wait — I walked in and waited over an hour. It’s a popular choice, especially for families. The food was above average, and I enjoyed the dishes overall. However, the staff isn’t necessarily the friendliest, and with how busy they are, you’ll need a bit of patience to get their attention. I’d definitely go back for the food, but I’ll aim for a less crowded time or season.

Sarabeth’s on Central Park South is a small and charming spot with a cozy, elegant vibe. The prices are on the higher side, but it’s understandable given the prime location. The portions are satisfying—definitely not oversized, but just right—and the food is absolutely delicious. Each dish is beautifully presented, adding to the overall experience. It’s a great place for a leisurely breakfast or brunch, especially if you’re looking for something special while exploring the area. The service is attentive, and the ambiance makes it feel like a little escape from the city buzz. If you’re in the neighborhood and want to treat yourself, it’s definitely worth a visit! 😀

Outstanding brunch, and great service. Crab and avocado appetizer was light and fresh. Shrimp cocktail was beautiful but just okay. Pancakes and eggs were excellent, but (pork) bacon was "next level" - absolutely delicious. We tried the special Filet Mignon Benedict; it was tasty but the cut of steak didn't deserve filet status IMHO. On to dessert, the cheesecake was awesome. To drink, the Manhattan was so good I ordered a 2nd one. Ambience was nice but pretty standard for NYC - even though it's across from Central Park there's not much of a view. But don't let that stop you -- Make your reservations and don't miss this place..

The location, service, and ambiance are great. The food presentation is also top-notch! However, the flavour could be enhanced. We felt that all the dishes needed a stronger 'punch' of flavour. We ordered the eggs Benedict, the farmer's omelet, and the French toast. They were okay, but not great. I'm not sure if I'd recommend the place unless you want to experience a brunch close to Central Park.

Honestly, everyone raves about their breakfast so had to try it. Tried their avocado toast (phenomenal), lemon & ricotta pancakes (average), buttermilk pancakes (lovely), truffle scramble eggs (average) & orange juice (great portion and fresh). To add, loved the butter that came along with the pancakes so good.

The service was great. We were seated immediately in a nice booth. The menu needs to be more descriptive it doesn’t give a good description of the food and I was confused when the appetizers came out because they did not look like how the menu made it sound. My eggs Benedict were good but the portion was small. The burger was the driest burger ever and they overcooked it. AND DO NOT GET THE grilled cheese the grilled cheese itself is very small and it has little to no butter. The tomato soup is not tomato soup it’s more of a lobster bisque with a ton of veggies. Overall I would not recommend anything but the eggs.

The location is fantastic, right by Central Park, making it perfect for a leisurely brunch. The food was exceptional, with a great variety of delicious dishes. I particularly enjoyed the Buttermilk Pancakes and the Fat & Fluffy French Toast. The Spinach & Goat Cheese Omelette was also delightful. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, and the service was top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff. It’s a busy place, but the food is delicious with generous portions, and the service is excellent. Prices are on the higher side.

What a great find!! We had a reservation at 10 AM and were immediately seated! Intimate table for 2, quick service for drink orders. The coffee was great! We both ordered the Farmer’s Omelette, shared a side of potatoes! SO SO good! Perfect start to our day to skip across the street and explore Central Park! It was also nice that we never felt rushed! The timing of everything, from drinks, food and the check at the end was so comfortable. Can’t wait to return next time we’re in town.