At this popular NoLita gem, hearty square pies packed with crispy pepperoni cups steal the show, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
"It has come to our attention by way of food writer Joe Rosenthal that Prince Street Pizza has a history of racial discrimination and racist messaging both online and in the restaurant (read more here). As a response to these instances, we have removed Prince Street Pizza from our guides in which they were previously featured. Prince Street Pizza is a slice shop in Nolita that specializes in hefty, square pies with spicy, garlicky tomato sauce. There are a bunch of options for toppings, but you’ll notice most people opting for the thick pepperoni cups. NYC Feature Owners Of Prince Street Pizza Step Down After Several Accounts Of Racial Discrimination" - Team Infatuation
"Prince Street Pizza, originally founded in New York's Nolita neighborhood in 2012 by Frank Morano, is known for its Spicy Spring Sicilian square. The pizzeria is expanding to Chicago, with its first Midwest location opening in West Loop. Despite past controversies involving the founder, the restaurant's popularity continues to grow, with multiple locations across the USA and Canada. The Chicago outlet will offer the same iconic slices and pies, made daily from scratch. Local operator David Choi, founder of Seoul Taco, will oversee the Chicago location, aiming to bring the acclaimed pizza to the city's diverse food scene." - Ashok Selvam
"Prince Street won out with a 7.7, but overall, the slices were 'underwhelming.'" - Luke Fortney
"The first-ever One Bite Pizza Fest was Portnoy’s attempt to bring together his favorite pizzerias, including Prince Street Pizza in New York for ticket buyers." - Jaya Saxena
"More than 30 of the pizzerias Portnoy rated are slated to participate in the inaugural One Bite Pizza Festival in Brooklyn." - Melissa McCart