L'Isola

This place was probably good 5-10 years ago, now it’s overrated. Food was bland, really nothing special. We ordered simple dishes but somehow the restaurant wasn’t able to make them tasty. Fish was almost frozen, pasta was bland. Extremely expensive (even for St. Barth), simple burrata shouldn’t be 70€ 👀

Delicious food, literally cleaned the plate to the piece from starters to mains to dessert. Excellent service, the menu has a variety of tasty options, and the staff is friendly and attentive. A great place for a satisfying meal!

This was hands down one of my favorite meals that we had while on the island (and we ate a lot of good food). All of the food was delicious! Super traditional, simple, but perfectly done Italian food. The dining room is traditional and charming and the service is top notch. Beef carpaccio, grilled octopus, lobster pasta, shrimp pasta, grilled sea bass, truffle mashed potatoes, and a perfectly cooked filet. *drool* I’m making myself hungry posting about this. If you want a nice dinner in St. Barths, this is definitely one of the places you should stop. Make sure to make a reservation.

Our dinning here was awesome. High quality service in a beautiful space. Everyone was speaking Italian. Really great cocktails. We actually returned one night for drinks. They can accommodate all group sizes. Excellent wine menu. The Tuscan soup was so good and so was the Milanese veal chop.

You don’t expect to find legit Italian on a tiny island in the Caribbean, but alas, this is it. This dark, intimate space is a serene sanctuary that turns out fantastic Italian classics, stunning pastas and offers a killer wine list. Servers are engaging and fun, offering great insight into the menu and tending to your every need. It doesn’t come cheap, but not much in St Barths does. Highly recommended for a date night or quiet dinner with friends.

L'isola. I've been here in 2008 and now again in 2023. It is a wonderful restaurant that has been updated and it is a beautiful restaurant with fantastic hosts, servers, managers, bartenders, chefs and everyone on the team! The delicious food has ALWAYS been delicious. The service always creates a magical evening and the chefs know how to make everything the best! We had a great time tonight and our guide through our meal Nicola, a smart Italian server, was a 5 star server for us, thank you Nicola. We are celebrating our 7th anniversary and this was another great St Barths restaurant we've been lucky to break bread at this week. St Barths truly is blessed with a diverse, creative, and high quality restaurant and hospitality community of people from around the world. L'Isola seems to be a consistent part of that community with delicious Italian food and service akin to that seen in large cities. Thank you to the team at L'Isola for making it a special night for me and my love.

For sure the best restaurant in St. Barths. As Italian myself, I can tell you that you will find the real italian cuisine, nothing fake. High quality ingredients at a high price, for sure, but you are in St. Barths. I return since 4 years, the staff is almost the same, always welcoming. Fabrizio the owner is not only a great businessman, but also an amazing person. Grazie di tutto ragazzi.

Food and drinks are good in a nice setting. However, service left a lot to be desired. Uncoordinated and slow service with clear preference for tables racking up a large bill. Service does not match price.