51

S&P Lunch

Restaurant · Flatiron District ·

S&P Lunch

Restaurant · Flatiron District ·
@newyorker
717 Postcards · 102 Cities

Playful Nostalgia and Honed Classics, at S&P Lunch | The New Yorker

"Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, the sandwich experts and playful nostalgists behind Court Street Grocers and the HiHi Room, are the new management of the venue previously known as Eisenberg's. They are proving to be gifted preservationists as well as savvy restaurateurs, renaming it S&P Sandwich Shop after the founders. With roughly three dozen sandwiches on the menu, including hamburgers, the classics have been honed rather than updated. The interior has been spruced up, maintaining its comfortable and worn edges, and the original forty-foot counter with vinyl swivel stools. Some of the dishes include a half cantaloupe filled with cottage cheese, iceberg lettuce topped with egg salad, and a Dusty Miller sundae." - Hannah Goldfield

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/11/21/playful-nostalgia-and-honed-classics-at-sp-lunch

Information

Old-school diner with classic sandwiches, egg creams, and more

pastrami sandwich
old school diner
tuna melt
latkes
egg cream
matzo ball soup
reuben sandwich
corned beef sandwich
Google Rating
4.6 (538)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Rated 8.0 by The Infatuation
8.0
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Food & Wine
Featured in
Featured in The New Yorker
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in
Featured on Bon Appetit
Featured in

174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Usually a wait
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Robert Sietsema/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
See full details

51

Information

Old-school diner with classic sandwiches, egg creams, and more

pastrami sandwich
old school diner
tuna melt
latkes
egg cream
matzo ball soup
reuben sandwich
corned beef sandwich
Google Rating
4.6 (538)
Yelp Rating
4.4
Rated 8.0 by The Infatuation
8.0
Featured in Eater
Featured in
Featured in Food & Wine
Featured in
Featured in The New Yorker
Featured in
Featured in Grub Street
Featured in
Featured on Bon Appetit
Featured in

174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Usually a wait
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Robert Sietsema/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by Melanie Landsman/Eater NY
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by David A. Lee
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
S&P Lunch by null
See full details

More Places For You

Flyfish Club

Restaurant · Lower East Side

Members-only club with upscale dining, live music, and lounges

15 Postcards

No More Cafe

Cocktail bar · East Village

Zero-proof cocktails, small plates, live music, chic ambiance

1 Postcard

Randall’s Barbecue

Barbecue restaurant · Lower East Side

Barbecue classics, unique dishes, draft beers, full bar

7 Postcards

Sami & Susu

Mediterranean restaurant · Lower East Side

Mediterranean restaurant with seasonal Jewish-Sephardic dishes and wine

30 Postcards

Casa Tua New York

Restaurant · Upper East Side

Italian-inspired lifestyle restaurant, lounge, and members' club

8 Postcards

W 53rd St

· Midtown West

Pan-Asian dining with truffle soup dumplings & art

6 Postcards

Mommy Pai’s

Takeout Restaurant · Nolita

Thai chicken fingers & tropical fruit drinks with unique sauces

17 Postcards

Cecily

Restaurant · Greenpoint

Mussel toast, seasonal produce, wine list, profit-sharing model

13 Postcards

Lei

Wine bar · Chinatown

Wine bar with 500+ global selections & Chinese dishes

19 Postcards

Pinch Chinese

Chinese restaurant · SoHo

Soup dumplings and Peking duck from Din Tai Fung alum

30 Postcards