6
Best sushi on the island— tuna sandwich, teriyaki chicken salad and banana tempura for dessert.
Spicy tuna sandwich, teriyaki chicken salad, fresh sushi
688 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976 Get directions
$30–50
Sushi restaurant · Water Mill
Japanese dining with Wagyu fried rice and Uni pasta
6 Postcards
Restaurant · Water Mill
Exclusive club: seafood, steaks, jazz, bocce, concierge
1 Postcard
Wellness hotel · Water Mill
Japanese-inspired wellness retreat with spa, yoga, farm-to-table meals
20 Postcards
Greek restaurant · Water Mill
Mediterranean cuisine, fine wine, craft cocktails, live music
4 Postcards
Art museum · Water Mill
Art museum featuring regional artists, modern architecture
8 Postcards
Upscale diner plates like lobster rolls and clambakes; chic retro decor
Art center · Water Mill
Global arts residency hub with contemporary art & programming
Seafood restaurant · Water Mill
Seafood staples, lobster rolls, clam chowder, and burgers
2 Postcards
Local history museum · Water Mill
Historic operating grist mill museum with art, history, quilts
0 Postcards
Coffee shop · Water Mill
Pastries, coffee, breakfast & lunch with outdoor seating