"The burger at this unpretentious, preppy pub is no modern-day smashburger. It’s a thick patty on a gently toasted bun, and best with grilled onions and bacon, plus their cottage fries. Sure, it could benefit from a little (or a lot) more salt, but the whiff of old cigarette smoke lingering in the dark wood walls, the instantly recognizable green checkered tablecloths, and the watermelon-centric art everywhere make up for any lack of seasoning. Bring cash and get a drink at the bar while you wait for a table. Chili, cheeseburger, cottage fries, key lime pie" - molly fitzpatrick, willa moore, will hartman, bryan kim, sonal shah