"In a restored carriage house with an open fireplace, Vinegar Hill House in Dumbo feels like a rustic farmhouse with an ivy-covered yard. Of their two private dining rooms—the Fireside Room has its own working fireplace, while the Carriage House has access to the garden and seats up to 32. Cast iron chicken, farmstead cheese, and seasonal produce are on the menu, with packages starting from $75 per person, with a $1,300 minimum F&B spend." - neha talreja, bryan kim, hannah albertine, will hartman