"For 20 years, the 35 or so seats in Neptune have been some of the toughest and tightest in town. And that’s not likely to change anytime soon, because people like us keep putting it on best-of lists. You’ll find the expected lobster roll and chowder, plus dishes you might not have considered, like the blue fish johnnycake and burger. The good news is that almost everything here is excellent. It’s not necessarily an easy meal experience, but it’s always worth the hassle." - dan secatore, tanya edwards