L&B Spumoni Gardens

"This old-school Bensonhurst pizzeria, open since 1939, is a rewarding nice-weather destination with its outdoor setup, yet the indoor dining room (with an extensive menu of Italian American classics) is too often overlooked. Go here for pillowy square pies and the lesser known round ones. Slices are available too, but if you want toppings, you must order a pizza. Leave room for spumoni. This is a good spot for groups. There’s also a location in Dumbo." - Robert Sietsema, Eater Staff