Scarr's Pizza

25 Best Places for Pizza in New York City | Condé Nast Traveler

"The perpetual out-the-door line at Scarr's develops before the restaurant even opens, and for good reason: You can’t go wrong with a traditional cheese slice, with a darkened quality that makes the whole pie slightly crispier, and a sauce with a satisfying tang. But in addition to traditional slices, they also have a popular Hotboi Slice complete with beef pepperoni, jalapeños, and extra-hot honey. This spot even caters to vegans with options using NUMU vegan cheeses. There's a variety of soft drinks and bottled water, but there's also beer, natural wine, and guava margaritas to pair with your slice." - Andrea Whittle, Jessica Kelly